Skip to main content
replaced http://meta.codereview.stackexchange.com/ with https://codereview.meta.stackexchange.com/
Source Link
replaced http://meta.codereview.stackexchange.com/ with https://codereview.meta.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

In thisthis question, the poster noticed that the question was closed rather than being migrated. Comments say that the question was cross-posted, so it was just closed on our site.

In the comments, it appears that some people think that we should tell the poster to re-post to the site where the question would be on-topic.

On Stack Overflow, most people are strongly against telling people to cross-post. Is this sentiment the same across all SE sites?

I know we are Beta, so I assume it is harder for us to migrate questions to other sites. Have we fallen into the mindset that the user should delete their post here and re-post on the site where their question will be on-topic?

Why are we closing these questions as opposed to migrating them?

Migrating these questions would give a link back to Code Review which, in my opinion, would be a good advertisement for our site inside the SE network.

In this question, the poster noticed that the question was closed rather than being migrated. Comments say that the question was cross-posted, so it was just closed on our site.

In the comments, it appears that some people think that we should tell the poster to re-post to the site where the question would be on-topic.

On Stack Overflow, most people are strongly against telling people to cross-post. Is this sentiment the same across all SE sites?

I know we are Beta, so I assume it is harder for us to migrate questions to other sites. Have we fallen into the mindset that the user should delete their post here and re-post on the site where their question will be on-topic?

Why are we closing these questions as opposed to migrating them?

Migrating these questions would give a link back to Code Review which, in my opinion, would be a good advertisement for our site inside the SE network.

In this question, the poster noticed that the question was closed rather than being migrated. Comments say that the question was cross-posted, so it was just closed on our site.

In the comments, it appears that some people think that we should tell the poster to re-post to the site where the question would be on-topic.

On Stack Overflow, most people are strongly against telling people to cross-post. Is this sentiment the same across all SE sites?

I know we are Beta, so I assume it is harder for us to migrate questions to other sites. Have we fallen into the mindset that the user should delete their post here and re-post on the site where their question will be on-topic?

Why are we closing these questions as opposed to migrating them?

Migrating these questions would give a link back to Code Review which, in my opinion, would be a good advertisement for our site inside the SE network.

deleted 102 characters in body; edited tags; edited title
Source Link
Jamal
  • 35.2k
  • 2
  • 54
  • 106

Migrating Questionsquestions to StackoverflowStack Overflow

in this Question,In Why was a Question suitable for Stack Overflow closed instead of being migratedthis question, the Poster noticesposter noticed that the question iswas closed rather than being migrated. comments Comments say that the question was cross posted-posted, so it was just closed on our site.

inIn the comments, it appears that some people think that we should tell the poster to re-post to the site where the question would be on-topic.

on StackoverflowOn Stack Overflow, most people are strongly against telling people to cross post, is-post. Is this sentiment the same across all SE sites?

I know we are Beta, so I assume it is harder for us to migrate (I assume)questions to other sites. have Have we fallen into the mindset that the user should delete theretheir post here and repostre-post on the site where their question will be on topic-topic?

whyWhy are we closing these questions as opposed to migrating them?

Migrating these questions would give a link back to CodeReview whichCode Review which, in my opinion, would be a good advertisement for our site inside the SE network (in my opinion).

several Questions, just curious.

Migrating Questions to Stackoverflow

in this Question, Why was a Question suitable for Stack Overflow closed instead of being migrated, the Poster notices that the question is closed rather than migrated. comments say that the question was cross posted, so it was just closed on our site.

in the comments it appears that some people think that we should tell the poster to re-post to the site where the question would be on-topic.

on Stackoverflow most people are strongly against telling people to cross post, is this sentiment the same across all SE sites?

I know we are Beta so it is harder for us to migrate (I assume) to other sites. have we fallen into the mindset that the user should delete there post here and repost on the site where their question will be on topic?

why are we closing these questions as opposed to migrating them?

Migrating these questions would give a link back to CodeReview which would be a good advertisement for our site inside the SE network (in my opinion).

several Questions, just curious.

Migrating questions to Stack Overflow

In this question, the poster noticed that the question was closed rather than being migrated. Comments say that the question was cross-posted, so it was just closed on our site.

In the comments, it appears that some people think that we should tell the poster to re-post to the site where the question would be on-topic.

On Stack Overflow, most people are strongly against telling people to cross-post. Is this sentiment the same across all SE sites?

I know we are Beta, so I assume it is harder for us to migrate questions to other sites. Have we fallen into the mindset that the user should delete their post here and re-post on the site where their question will be on-topic?

Why are we closing these questions as opposed to migrating them?

Migrating these questions would give a link back to Code Review which, in my opinion, would be a good advertisement for our site inside the SE network.

Source Link
Malachi
  • 29.1k
  • 23
  • 49
Loading