_{This is kind of a follow up question to this http://stackoverflow.com/questions/23743285/model-view-controller-and-callbacks, but I wanted to post it separately, because its kind of a different topic.}

_{This is kind of a follow up question to this https://stackoverflow.com/questions/23743285/model-view-controller-and-callbacks, but I wanted to post it separately, because its kind of a different topic.}

this is kind of a follow up question to this http://stackoverflow.com/questions/23743285/model-view-controller-and-callbacks, but i wanted to post it seperatly, cause its kind of a different topic.

I'm working on a multiplayer cardgame for the android platform. I split the project into MVC which fits the needs pretty good, but im currently stuck cause i cant figure out a good way to communicate between the different parts.

I have everything setup and working with the contoller beeing a big state machine, which is called over and over from the gameloop, and calls getter methods from the gui and the android/network part to get the input. The input itself in the gui and network is set by inputlisteners that set a local variable which i read in the getter method.

So far so good, this is working. But my problem is, the controller has to check every input seperatly,so if i want to add a input i have to check in which states its valid and call the getter method from all these states. This is not good, and lets the code look pretty ugly, makes additions uncomfortable and adds redudance.

SO what i got from the question i mentioned above is, that some kind of command or event pattern will fit my needs. What i want to do is, create a shared and threadsafe queue in the controller and instead of calling all these getter methods, i just check the queue for new input and proceed it. On the other side, the gui and network dont have all these getters, but instead create an event or command and send it to the controller through, for example, observer/obsererable.

Now my problem: I cant figure out a way, for these commands/events to fit a common Interface (which the queue can store) and still transport different kind of data (button clicks, cards that are played, the player id the command comes from, synchronization data etc.).

If i design the communication as command pattern, i have to stick all the information thats needed to execute the command into it when its created, thats impossible cause the gui or network has no knowledge of all the things the controller needs to execute stuff that needs to be done when for example a card is played. I thought about getting this sutff into the command when executing it. But over all the different commands i have, i would need all the information the controller has, and thus give the command a reference to the controller which would make everthing in it public, which is real bad design i guess.

So, i could try some kind of event pattern. I have to transport data in the event. So, like the command, i would have an interface, which all events have in common, and can be stored in the shared queue. I could create a big enum with all the different events that a are possible, save one of these enums in the acctual event, and build a big switchcause for the events, to proceed different stuff for different events. the problem here: i have different data for all the events. But i need a common interface, to store the events in a queue. How do i get the specific data, if i can only access the event through the interface  ? Even if that wouldnt be a problem, im creating another big switch case, which looks ugly, and when i want to add a new event, i have to create the event itself, the case, the enum, and the method thats called with the data.

I could ofcourse check the event with the enum and cast it to its typ, so i can call eventtype specific methods that give me the data i need, but that looks like bad design too.

I'm thankful for any input on this.

Thanks in advance.

_{This is kind of a follow up question to this http://stackoverflow.com/questions/23743285/model-view-controller-and-callbacks, but I wanted to post it separately, because its kind of a different topic.}

I'm working on a multiplayer cardgame for the Android platform. I split the project into MVC which fits the needs pretty good, but I'm currently stuck because I can't figure out a good way to communicate between the different parts.

I have everything setup and working with the controller being a big state machine, which is called over and over from the gameloop, and calls getter methods from the GUI and the android/network part to get the input. The input itself in the GUI and network is set by inputlisteners that set a local variable which I read in the getter method.

So far so good, this is working. But my problem is, the controller has to check every input separately,so if I want to add an input I have to check in which states its valid and call the getter method from all these states. This is not good, and lets the code look pretty ugly, makes additions uncomfortable and adds redundance.

So what I've got from the question I mentioned above is that some kind of command or event pattern will fit my needs. What I want to do is to create a shared and threadsafe queue in the controller and instead of calling all these getter methods, I just check the queue for new input and proceed it. On the other side, the GUI and network don't have all these getters, but instead create an event or command and send it to the controller through, for example, observer/observable.

Now my problem: I can't figure out a way, for these commands/events to fit a common interface (which the queue can store) and still transport different kind of data (button clicks, cards that are played, the player id the command comes from, synchronization data etc.).

If I design the communication as command pattern, I have to stick all the information that is needed to execute the command into it when its created, that's impossible because the GUI or network has no knowledge of all the things the controller needs to execute stuff that needs to be done when for example a card is played. 

I thought about getting this stuff into the command when executing it. But over all the different commands I have, I would need all the information the controller has, and thus give the command a reference to the controller which would make everything in it public, which is real bad design I guess.

So, I could try some kind of event pattern. I have to transport data in the event. So, like the command, I would have an interface, which all events have in common, and can be stored in the shared queue. I could create a big enum with all the different events that a are possible, save one of these enums in the actual event, and build a big switch case for the events, to proceed different stuff for different events.

The problem here: I have different data for all the events. But I need a common interface, to store the events in a queue. How do I get the specific data, if I can only access the event through the interface? 

Even if that wouldn't be a problem, I'm creating another big switch case, which looks ugly, and when i want to add a new event, I have to create the event itself, the case, the enum, and the method that's called with the data.

I could of course check the event with the enum and cast it to its type, so I can call event type specific methods that give me the data I need, but that looks like bad design too.