#Ruby, 204+1 = 205 bytes

Requires the -n flag.

d=[%w"It would be extremely painful... for you!",%w"If I pull that off will you die? You're a big guy."]
n=%w"BANE CIA"
("%b"%$_).scan(/((.)\2*)/).map{|i,b|puts n[k=b.to_i]+': '+d[k].slice!(0,i.size)*' '}

Ruby, 204+1 = 205 bytes

Requires the -n flag.

d=[%w"It would be extremely painful... for you!",%w"If I pull that off will you die? You're a big guy."]
n=%w"BANE CIA"
("%b"%$_).scan(/((.)\2*)/).map{|i,b|puts n[k=b.to_i]+': '+d[k].slice!(0,i.size)*' '}