Skip to main content
added 820 characters in body
Source Link
rumtscho
  • 143.4k
  • 47
  • 318
  • 586

Yes, itrising is very dependent on gluten. You cannotIn almost all cases, you won't get the typical texture of a classic breadany rising without thea gluten of wheat-rich flour.

If Even if you have to bakeuse wheat flour, but one that has the wrong proportion of gluten-free, you can do some limited yeast baking by usingwill get a gluten-free flour in combination with thickeners, such as guar gumdisappointing rise. The achievable textures are closeIf you were to the cottony white loaves introduced by American industrial productiontry making a bread recipe calling for AP flour (I've forgotten their English name, sorry8-10% gluten) with bagel flour (14- in Germany they are called "bread15% gluten) or a recipe for toasting"bread flour (12ish percent gluten) with pastry flour (6% gluten), one prominent problem will be very little rising.

The flours you use for thisI said "in almost all cases" and not "in all", because some clever people have found limited ways to consist of starch - so you can use rice flour, but not something like defatted peanut flourget rising without gluten. Also, the process for thisThe limitations of such baking is so finicky that it almost doesn't pay to experimentare:

  • you can't achieve most traditional bread textures with this kind of baking. You only get bread that resembles the cottony, light bread with soft crust that is the prototypical bread in an American supermarket.
  • you can't use any gluten-free flour. What you need is a flour that is almost pure starch. Rice flour can be used to make a gluten free bread recipe, defatted peanut flour won't work well.
  • You have to use something to replace the gluten, typically a combination of thickeners like guar gum.
  • It is a very finicky process. Making up your own recipes by experimentation will have an immense failure rate. Instead, you should follow existing recipes to the letter, and live with the fact that you will need quite some exercise to learn to execute them well, if the recipe was any good to start with.

So, unlessif you are very determinedmanage your expectations and are willing to live withinvest some time in choosing and learning a failure rate close to thatgood recipe, you can get risen gluten-free bread of drug developmenta certain type. InsteadIn that sense, you should follow published recipesyeast bread doesn't strictly "require" gluten to the letterrise, but for this branch of baking - itmost practical purposes, the answer is difficult enough to get thesequite close to work"yes it does".

Yes, it is very dependent on gluten. You cannot get the typical texture of a classic bread without the gluten of wheat flour.

If you have to bake gluten-free, you can do some limited yeast baking by using a gluten-free flour in combination with thickeners, such as guar gum. The achievable textures are close to the cottony white loaves introduced by American industrial production (I've forgotten their English name, sorry - in Germany they are called "bread for toasting").

The flours you use for this have to consist of starch - so you can use rice flour, but not something like defatted peanut flour. Also, the process for this baking is so finicky that it almost doesn't pay to experiment, unless you are very determined and are willing to live with a failure rate close to that of drug development. Instead, you should follow published recipes to the letter for this branch of baking - it is difficult enough to get these to work.

Yes, rising is very dependent on gluten. In almost all cases, you won't get any rising without a gluten-rich flour. Even if you use wheat flour, but one that has the wrong proportion of gluten, you will get a disappointing rise. If you were to try making a bread recipe calling for AP flour (8-10% gluten) with bagel flour (14-15% gluten) or a recipe for bread flour (12ish percent gluten) with pastry flour (6% gluten), one prominent problem will be very little rising.

I said "in almost all cases" and not "in all", because some clever people have found limited ways to get rising without gluten. The limitations of such baking are:

  • you can't achieve most traditional bread textures with this kind of baking. You only get bread that resembles the cottony, light bread with soft crust that is the prototypical bread in an American supermarket.
  • you can't use any gluten-free flour. What you need is a flour that is almost pure starch. Rice flour can be used to make a gluten free bread recipe, defatted peanut flour won't work well.
  • You have to use something to replace the gluten, typically a combination of thickeners like guar gum.
  • It is a very finicky process. Making up your own recipes by experimentation will have an immense failure rate. Instead, you should follow existing recipes to the letter, and live with the fact that you will need quite some exercise to learn to execute them well, if the recipe was any good to start with.

So, if you manage your expectations and invest some time in choosing and learning a good recipe, you can get risen gluten-free bread of a certain type. In that sense, yeast bread doesn't strictly "require" gluten to rise, but for most practical purposes, the answer is quite close to "yes it does".

Source Link
rumtscho
  • 143.4k
  • 47
  • 318
  • 586

Yes, it is very dependent on gluten. You cannot get the typical texture of a classic bread without the gluten of wheat flour.

If you have to bake gluten-free, you can do some limited yeast baking by using a gluten-free flour in combination with thickeners, such as guar gum. The achievable textures are close to the cottony white loaves introduced by American industrial production (I've forgotten their English name, sorry - in Germany they are called "bread for toasting").

The flours you use for this have to consist of starch - so you can use rice flour, but not something like defatted peanut flour. Also, the process for this baking is so finicky that it almost doesn't pay to experiment, unless you are very determined and are willing to live with a failure rate close to that of drug development. Instead, you should follow published recipes to the letter for this branch of baking - it is difficult enough to get these to work.