Strawberry Buttermilk

Guaranteed frozen delivery
Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.
Nationwide delivery
We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.
Instagram-worthy unboxing
Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.804598 / 5 from 174 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Strawberry Buttermilk ice cream is celebrated for its bright, fresh strawberry flavor and smooth, creamy texture. While some customers love the strawberry buttermilk combination, opinions vary. The overall flavor is highly praised for being delicious and unique.

Summary topics

Strawberry Buttermilk (4%): Customers expressed differing viewpoints regarding the strawberry buttermilk, with some loving it and others finding it lacking.
Strawberry Flavor (15%): Customers keep praising the strawberry flavor, describing it as the best and perfect for all tastes.
Creamy Texture (5%): Customers appreciated the perfect creamy texture of the product, which was mentioned multiple times in the reviews.
Overall Flavor (51%): A substantial number of customers appreciated the flavor, describing it as smooth, great, delicious, and unique.

Review topics: [flavor, packaging, selection, order, texture, sweetness, gift, ice cream, goodness, joy, strawberry, jeni, strawberry buttermilk, pint, cream, tang].

Review highlights

"really really loved this flavor, the texture and the touch of buttermilk was perfect." — Margaret W.
"Delicious flavor, perfect creamy texture." — Holleen K.
"The sweet and creamy strawberry flavor with a hint of tartness is a perfect blend." — Venice S.

Reviews

Son’s number one pick

"Surprisingly this is my son’s favorite. He said the flavor became more intense towards the bottom of the pint lol"

— Leah D. (5/5)

The taste of summer

"This is the FLOAT! My personal favorite FLavor of All Time. It's smooth and silky with a subtle and gentle bite of tang. The strawberry flavor reminds me of summer, and it brings me back to some fond childhood memories of starwberry picking and all that followed: jam, shortcake and a belly full of freshly picked berries in the field"

— Don B. (5/5)

Yum!

"Delicious. And I'm not typically a strawberry ice cream fan - smooth, creamy, just the right amount of sweet."

— Abbie M. (5/5)

Not great not bad

"Good but nothing special. It could use more strawberries imo!"

— Dilman B. (4/5)

Yummy and lovely

"So light and creamy with just a nice tang!"

— Mary S. (5/5)

Thank you Jeni’s Icecream!

"Jeni’s ice cream is our favorite!"

— Amy H. (5/5)

97 year old gave it a thumbs up

"We sent 5 pints to my mother in law for her Mother’s Day gift. She just turned 97 in April and is ecstatic with the selection we sent stating it was the very best."

— Linda G. (5/5)

"Creamy and very good."

— Andre'-P. F. (5/5)