Skip to main content
Post Reopened by Mittens, José Carlos Santos, Another User, Liding Yao, David Gao
Post Closed as "Not suitable for this site" by Ѕᴀᴀᴅ, user91500, Thinh Dinh, amWhy, Parcly Taxel
Became Hot Network Question
More-informative title; formatting tweaks
Source Link
Blue
  • 85.3k
  • 16
  • 131
  • 270

Solvable Does anyone have any cubics that are solvable by hand and yield "pretty" roots?

I've been playing around with Cardano's formula, and I've come away a little bit disappointed : I'm under the impression that for a polynomial with rational coefficients, the formulas yield an intractable mess unless either at least one root is rational (in which case one can just use the rational root theorem) or at least one root is some variation on cos(pi/9)$\cos(\pi/9)$ or cos(pi/7)$\cos(\pi/7)$, essentially because these numbers have degree 3 minimal polynomials :. See Wikipedia's https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimal_polynomial_of_2cos(2pi/n)"Minimal polynomial of $2\cos(2\pi/n)$" entry.

Does anyone have any cubics that are solvable by hand and yield "pretty" roots ?

Does anyone have any cubics that are solvable by hand and yield "pretty" roots ?

Solvable cubics

I've been playing around with Cardano's formula, and I've come away a little bit disappointed : I'm under the impression that for a polynomial with rational coefficients, the formulas yield an intractable mess unless either at least one root is rational (in which case one can just use the rational root theorem) or at least one root is some variation on cos(pi/9) or cos(pi/7), essentially because these numbers have degree 3 minimal polynomials : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimal_polynomial_of_2cos(2pi/n)

Does anyone have any cubics that are solvable by hand and yield "pretty" roots ?

Does anyone have any cubics that are solvable by hand and yield "pretty" roots?

I've been playing around with Cardano's formula, and I've come away a little bit disappointed : I'm under the impression that for a polynomial with rational coefficients, the formulas yield an intractable mess unless either at least one root is rational (in which case one can just use the rational root theorem) or at least one root is some variation on $\cos(\pi/9)$ or $\cos(\pi/7)$, essentially because these numbers have degree 3 minimal polynomials. See Wikipedia's "Minimal polynomial of $2\cos(2\pi/n)$" entry.

Does anyone have any cubics that are solvable by hand and yield "pretty" roots ?

Source Link
Ert33
  • 559
  • 3
  • 11

Solvable cubics

I've been playing around with Cardano's formula, and I've come away a little bit disappointed : I'm under the impression that for a polynomial with rational coefficients, the formulas yield an intractable mess unless either at least one root is rational (in which case one can just use the rational root theorem) or at least one root is some variation on cos(pi/9) or cos(pi/7), essentially because these numbers have degree 3 minimal polynomials : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimal_polynomial_of_2cos(2pi/n)

Does anyone have any cubics that are solvable by hand and yield "pretty" roots ?