Skip to main content
replaced http://stackoverflow.com/ with https://stackoverflow.com/
Source Link

Once in a while I stumble on an answer that has a mini-rant at the top, often as the result of an anonymous down-vote. Sometimes these rants are just a sentence, but other times they stretch to a paragraph or two, sometimes even with formatting (bolded and italicized sections).

Personally I think they don't belong, but should I take it upon myself to remove the rants? Should I flag the answer? Leave a comment about the inappropriateness? Just do nothing?

Here's an example of such a rant, apparently added after there was a downvote or two (linking to a revision, in case it has been removed in the latest version):

http://stackoverflow.com/revisions/26111541/4https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/26111541/4:

[-1]-ed?

Tell the Community why?

all Keen DownVoter-s are welcome, however please do keep StackOverflow Netiquette which promotes cooperative style of work here -- so kindly express your reason ( yes, state an argument, post your improvement and add facts behind an opinion that you down-voted for ). Un-argumented downvoting is a poor practice in highly educated society, that StackOverflow Community strives to be. Thanks for your kind consideration.

Once in a while I stumble on an answer that has a mini-rant at the top, often as the result of an anonymous down-vote. Sometimes these rants are just a sentence, but other times they stretch to a paragraph or two, sometimes even with formatting (bolded and italicized sections).

Personally I think they don't belong, but should I take it upon myself to remove the rants? Should I flag the answer? Leave a comment about the inappropriateness? Just do nothing?

Here's an example of such a rant, apparently added after there was a downvote or two (linking to a revision, in case it has been removed in the latest version):

http://stackoverflow.com/revisions/26111541/4:

[-1]-ed?

Tell the Community why?

all Keen DownVoter-s are welcome, however please do keep StackOverflow Netiquette which promotes cooperative style of work here -- so kindly express your reason ( yes, state an argument, post your improvement and add facts behind an opinion that you down-voted for ). Un-argumented downvoting is a poor practice in highly educated society, that StackOverflow Community strives to be. Thanks for your kind consideration.

Once in a while I stumble on an answer that has a mini-rant at the top, often as the result of an anonymous down-vote. Sometimes these rants are just a sentence, but other times they stretch to a paragraph or two, sometimes even with formatting (bolded and italicized sections).

Personally I think they don't belong, but should I take it upon myself to remove the rants? Should I flag the answer? Leave a comment about the inappropriateness? Just do nothing?

Here's an example of such a rant, apparently added after there was a downvote or two (linking to a revision, in case it has been removed in the latest version):

https://stackoverflow.com/revisions/26111541/4:

[-1]-ed?

Tell the Community why?

all Keen DownVoter-s are welcome, however please do keep StackOverflow Netiquette which promotes cooperative style of work here -- so kindly express your reason ( yes, state an argument, post your improvement and add facts behind an opinion that you down-voted for ). Un-argumented downvoting is a poor practice in highly educated society, that StackOverflow Community strives to be. Thanks for your kind consideration.

added 498 characters in body
Source Link
Patrick Hofman
  • 157.7k
  • 11
  • 70
  • 85

Once in a while I stumble on an answer that has a mini-rant at the top, often as the result of an anonymous down-vote. Sometimes these rants are just a sentence, but other times they stretch to a paragraph or two, sometimes even with formatting (bolded and italicized sections).

Personally I think they don't belong, but should I take it upon myself to remove the rants? Should I flag the answer? Leave a comment about the inappropriateness? Just do nothing?

Here's an example of such a rant, apparently added after there was a downvote or two (linking to a revision, in case it has been removed in the latest version):

http://stackoverflow.com/revisions/26111541/4:

[-1]-ed?

Tell the Community why?

all Keen DownVoter-s are welcome, however please do keep StackOverflow Netiquette which promotes cooperative style of work here -- so kindly express your reason ( yes, state an argument, post your improvement and add facts behind an opinion that you down-voted for ). Un-argumented downvoting is a poor practice in highly educated society, that StackOverflow Community strives to be. Thanks for your kind consideration.

Once in a while I stumble on an answer that has a mini-rant at the top, often as the result of an anonymous down-vote. Sometimes these rants are just a sentence, but other times they stretch to a paragraph or two, sometimes even with formatting (bolded and italicized sections).

Personally I think they don't belong, but should I take it upon myself to remove the rants? Should I flag the answer? Leave a comment about the inappropriateness? Just do nothing?

Here's an example of such a rant, apparently added after there was a downvote or two (linking to a revision, in case it has been removed in the latest version):

http://stackoverflow.com/revisions/26111541/4

Once in a while I stumble on an answer that has a mini-rant at the top, often as the result of an anonymous down-vote. Sometimes these rants are just a sentence, but other times they stretch to a paragraph or two, sometimes even with formatting (bolded and italicized sections).

Personally I think they don't belong, but should I take it upon myself to remove the rants? Should I flag the answer? Leave a comment about the inappropriateness? Just do nothing?

Here's an example of such a rant, apparently added after there was a downvote or two (linking to a revision, in case it has been removed in the latest version):

http://stackoverflow.com/revisions/26111541/4:

[-1]-ed?

Tell the Community why?

all Keen DownVoter-s are welcome, however please do keep StackOverflow Netiquette which promotes cooperative style of work here -- so kindly express your reason ( yes, state an argument, post your improvement and add facts behind an opinion that you down-voted for ). Un-argumented downvoting is a poor practice in highly educated society, that StackOverflow Community strives to be. Thanks for your kind consideration.

Source Link
Bryan Oakley
  • 389.1k
  • 1
  • 26
  • 20

Should we edit answers to remove mini-rants?

Once in a while I stumble on an answer that has a mini-rant at the top, often as the result of an anonymous down-vote. Sometimes these rants are just a sentence, but other times they stretch to a paragraph or two, sometimes even with formatting (bolded and italicized sections).

Personally I think they don't belong, but should I take it upon myself to remove the rants? Should I flag the answer? Leave a comment about the inappropriateness? Just do nothing?

Here's an example of such a rant, apparently added after there was a downvote or two (linking to a revision, in case it has been removed in the latest version):

http://stackoverflow.com/revisions/26111541/4