Skip to main content
edited tags
Link
Marsroverr
  • 878
  • 16
  • 28
Edited post to apply to first question review queue as well
Source Link
Marsroverr
  • 878
  • 16
  • 28

Should the first answers review queuequeues include opinion-based questions & answers?

The first answersquestion and first answer review queuequeues also showsshow discussions posts and answers - I find this odd since most of the quality metrics for Q&A don't seem to apply, given replies "join the conversation" rather than answering the question and the questions themselves have entirely different goals. Also, since you can't downvote posts, the "thumbs down" button that doesn't actually do anything also doesn't count as "other action" for reviewing. Should they even be included in this queue at all?

Should the first answers review queue include opinion-based answers?

The first answers review queue also shows discussions answers - I find this odd since most of the quality metrics for Q&A don't seem to apply, given replies "join the conversation" rather than answering the question. Also, since you can't downvote posts, the "thumbs down" button that doesn't actually do anything also doesn't count as "other action" for reviewing. Should they even be included in this queue at all?

Should the review queues include opinion-based questions & answers?

The first question and first answer review queues also show discussions posts and answers - I find this odd since most of the quality metrics for Q&A don't seem to apply, given replies "join the conversation" rather than answering the question and the questions themselves have entirely different goals. Also, since you can't downvote posts, the "thumbs down" button that doesn't actually do anything also doesn't count as "other action" for reviewing. Should they even be included in this queue at all?

Became Hot Meta Post
Source Link
Marsroverr
  • 878
  • 16
  • 28

Should the first answers review queue include opinion-based answers?

The first answers review queue also shows discussions answers - I find this odd since most of the quality metrics for Q&A don't seem to apply, given replies "join the conversation" rather than answering the question. Also, since you can't downvote posts, the "thumbs down" button that doesn't actually do anything also doesn't count as "other action" for reviewing. Should they even be included in this queue at all?