Skip to main content
Removed mathjax and streamlined the proof of minimality a bit
Source Link
Pranay
  • 28.6k
  • 1
  • 63
  • 179

This should work.

  1. The colouring:

edge-coloruing

  1. The sequence:

5 R's followed by 5 B's.

Bonus:

Label the cities 0, …, 10 starting from Rome and going in anticlockwise direction. Then, starting from city $i$i, the number of clockwise steps ($c_i$ci) must be $i$i more than the number of anticlockwise steps ($a_i$ai) modulo 11, i.e., ci $c_i - a_i = i \mod 11$- ai = i mod 11. But we also want the total number of steps to be the same starting from any city. In particular, $c_0 + a_0 = c_1 + a_1$c0 + a0 = c1 + a1. If $c_0 \ne a_0$c0 ≠ a0, then we already need at least 11 steps, so we need $c_0 = a_0$must have c0 = a0. Then, $c_1 + a_1$c1 + a1 must be even, but then $c_1 - a_1 - 1$ must be an odd multiple of 11. If it is +11, then $c_1 + a_1 \ge 12$, which is more than the above solution. So it should bemeans c1 -11, in which case a1 = 11k+1, where k is $c_1+a_1 \ge 10$odd. For any other odd multiple of 11, the total number of stepsIt follows that c1 + a1 ≥ |11k+1| ≥ 10 since k is clearly largerodd. Therefore, the above solution is minimal.

This should work.

  1. The colouring:

edge-coloruing

  1. The sequence:

5 R's followed by 5 B's.

Bonus:

Label the cities 0, …, 10 starting from Rome and going in anticlockwise direction. Then, starting from city $i$, the number of clockwise steps ($c_i$) must be $i$ more than the number of anticlockwise steps ($a_i$) modulo 11, i.e., $c_i - a_i = i \mod 11$. But we also want the total number of steps to be the same starting from any city. In particular, $c_0 + a_0 = c_1 + a_1$. If $c_0 \ne a_0$, then we already need at least 11 steps, so we need $c_0 = a_0$. Then, $c_1 + a_1$ must be even, but then $c_1 - a_1 - 1$ must be an odd multiple of 11. If it is +11, then $c_1 + a_1 \ge 12$, which is more than the above solution. So it should be -11, in which case, $c_1+a_1 \ge 10$. For any other odd multiple of 11, the total number of steps is clearly larger. Therefore, the above solution is minimal.

This should work.

  1. The colouring:

edge-coloruing

  1. The sequence:

5 R's followed by 5 B's.

Bonus:

Label the cities 0, …, 10 starting from Rome and going in anticlockwise direction. Then, starting from city i, the number of clockwise steps (ci) must be i more than the number of anticlockwise steps (ai) modulo 11, i.e., ci - ai = i mod 11. But we also want the total number of steps to be the same starting from any city. In particular, c0 + a0 = c1 + a1. If c0 ≠ a0, then we already need at least 11 steps, so we must have c0 = a0. Then, c1 + a1 must be even, which means c1 - a1 = 11k+1, where k is odd. It follows that c1 + a1 ≥ |11k+1| ≥ 10 since k is odd. Therefore, the above solution is minimal.

Improved the solution
Source Link
Pranay
  • 28.6k
  • 1
  • 63
  • 179

This should work.

  1. The colouring:

edge-coloruing

  1. The sequence:

R, R, R, R, R, R, B, B, B, B, B, i.e., 65 R's followed by 5 B's.

Bonus:

Label the cities 0, …, 10 starting from Rome and going in anticlockwise direction. Then, starting from city $i$, the number of clockwise steps ($c_i$) must be $i$ more than the number of anticlockwise steps ($a_i$) modulo 11, i.e., $c_i - a_i = i \mod 11$. But we also want the total number of steps to be the same starting from any city. In particular, $c_0 + a_0 = c_1 + a_1$. If $c_0 = a_0$$c_0 \ne a_0$, then we already need at least 11 steps, so we need $c_0 = a_0$. Then, $c_1 + a_1$ must be even, but then $c_1 - a_1 - 1$ must be an odd multiple of 11. If it is +11, which meansthen $c_1 + a_1$ is at least 12$c_1 + a_1 \ge 12$, which is more than the above solution. ThereforeSo it should be -11, in which case, $c_0 - a_0$ is a nonzero$c_1+a_1 \ge 10$. For any other odd multiple of 11 and, the total number of steps is clearly larger. Therefore, the above solution is minimal.

This should work.

  1. The colouring:

edge-coloruing

  1. The sequence:

R, R, R, R, R, R, B, B, B, B, B, i.e., 6 R's followed by 5 B's.

Bonus:

Label the cities 0, …, 10 starting from Rome and going in anticlockwise direction. Then, starting from city $i$, the number of clockwise steps ($c_i$) must be $i$ more than the number of anticlockwise steps ($a_i$) modulo 11, i.e., $c_i - a_i = i \mod 11$. But we want the total number of steps to be the same starting from any city. In particular, $c_0 + a_0 = c_1 + a_1$. If $c_0 = a_0$, then $c_1 + a_1$ must be even, but then $c_1 - a_1 - 1$ must be an odd multiple of 11, which means $c_1 + a_1$ is at least 12 which is more than the above solution. Therefore, $c_0 - a_0$ is a nonzero multiple of 11 and the above solution is minimal.

This should work.

  1. The colouring:

edge-coloruing

  1. The sequence:

5 R's followed by 5 B's.

Bonus:

Label the cities 0, …, 10 starting from Rome and going in anticlockwise direction. Then, starting from city $i$, the number of clockwise steps ($c_i$) must be $i$ more than the number of anticlockwise steps ($a_i$) modulo 11, i.e., $c_i - a_i = i \mod 11$. But we also want the total number of steps to be the same starting from any city. In particular, $c_0 + a_0 = c_1 + a_1$. If $c_0 \ne a_0$, then we already need at least 11 steps, so we need $c_0 = a_0$. Then, $c_1 + a_1$ must be even, but then $c_1 - a_1 - 1$ must be an odd multiple of 11. If it is +11, then $c_1 + a_1 \ge 12$, which is more than the above solution. So it should be -11, in which case, $c_1+a_1 \ge 10$. For any other odd multiple of 11, the total number of steps is clearly larger. Therefore, the above solution is minimal.

Rollback to Revision 2
Source Link
Pranay
  • 28.6k
  • 1
  • 63
  • 179

This should work.

  1. The colouring:

edge-coloruing

  1. The sequence:

R, R, R, R, R, R, B, B, B, B, B, i.e., 6 R's followed by 5 B's.

Bonus:

Label the cities 0, …, 10 starting from Rome and going in anticlockwise direction. Then, starting from city $i$, the number of clockwise steps ($c_i$) must be $i$ more than the number of anticlockwise steps ($a_i$) modulo 11, i.e., $c_i - a_i = i \mod 11$. But we want the total number of steps to be the same starting from any city. In particular, $c_0 + a_0 = c_1 + a_1$. If $c_0 = a_0$, then $c_1 + a_1$ must be even, but then $c_1 - a_1 - 1$ must be an odd multiple of 11, which means $c_1 + a_1$ is at least 12 which is more than the above solution. Therefore, $c_0 - a_0$ is a nonzero multiple of 11 and the above solution is minimal.

This should work.

  1. The colouring:

edge-coloruing

  1. The sequence:

R, R, R, R, R, R, B, B, B, B, B, i.e., 6 R's followed by 5 B's.

This should work.

  1. The colouring:

edge-coloruing

  1. The sequence:

R, R, R, R, R, R, B, B, B, B, B, i.e., 6 R's followed by 5 B's.

Bonus:

Label the cities 0, …, 10 starting from Rome and going in anticlockwise direction. Then, starting from city $i$, the number of clockwise steps ($c_i$) must be $i$ more than the number of anticlockwise steps ($a_i$) modulo 11, i.e., $c_i - a_i = i \mod 11$. But we want the total number of steps to be the same starting from any city. In particular, $c_0 + a_0 = c_1 + a_1$. If $c_0 = a_0$, then $c_1 + a_1$ must be even, but then $c_1 - a_1 - 1$ must be an odd multiple of 11, which means $c_1 + a_1$ is at least 12 which is more than the above solution. Therefore, $c_0 - a_0$ is a nonzero multiple of 11 and the above solution is minimal.

added 292 characters in body
Source Link
Pranay
  • 28.6k
  • 1
  • 63
  • 179
Loading
added 292 characters in body
Source Link
Pranay
  • 28.6k
  • 1
  • 63
  • 179
Loading
Source Link
Pranay
  • 28.6k
  • 1
  • 63
  • 179
Loading