I definitely never expected this! I am just a food blogger who is only a decent, but not yet great cook (though I’m working on it, darn it!), so I don’t usually generate so much buzz. I thought maybe my linked friends might read this, but I never foresaw this overwhelming response. I am surprised and humbled. Food bloggers are a fantastic bunch.
My post has been linked now/discussed by almost 50 blogs and forums (thank you and wow!!) and in reading through them all I saw that more often than not, people were angry with
Did I post what really happened?
I absolutely did and here’s why.
For one, I have integrity. I know that this is the internet and sometimes it’s hard to fully judge another’s character. So all I can tell you is that I am an extremely sincere and honest person. I can’t convince anyone of that with these words on paper (so to speak), but take it as you will.
Secondly, I had to tell the truth because there was no other option. What I mean is, if Deborah came back and read this and I misrepresented the exchange, she would be able to post her version and tell you about it herself.
Was this woman an intern or a “lackey?”
No, she is their named PR rep. Seek her name out alongside ATK and you will see that for yourself.
Has
I doubt it. I think if that were the case, I would have received an email by now.
Was I rude, snippy, bitchy,
But do I think I was? Yeah, I kind of do. Perhaps I judge myself harshly because in the past I was not always the person I am now, so I am always on the lookout for those qualities in myself. Therefore, on that basis, I agree that I probably should not have gotten so annoyed. I recognize that I was argumentative and difficult. I also recognize that I was fighting a losing battle by continuing to email her. No one wins in an internet/email fight. I’ve been meandering around the web for about 12 years now, so I knew that.
But as much as I focus on personal growth in day-to-day living, and strive to be a spiritually evolved person, I am only human. I felt like I was being condescended to and I got angry and defensive. These things happen.
As for using the word “fuckers” at the end of my post, I can only smile and say that I tend to curse a bit and I was just being honest in my frustration. It’s my blog and I am allowed to speak as I wish. I have to wonder if I had used the word “jerks” if anyone would have even blinked.
Did I actually try to post someone else’s recipe and pass it off as my own?
No. If you were someone who remarked that I did, I implore you to reread what occurred. I posted the recipe, explained that I made modifications and then under the recipe title, I wrote:
“courtesy of XXXX (my friend’s blog) via Cook’s Country”
If, at the time, I had understood the law regarding modifications making a recipe “yours,” I never would have mentioned CC in the first place.
And if you read my previous posts, you can see that in the past, like all of us have, I linked and credited anyone whose exact recipes, or even ideas, I have used. If you find one where I didn’t, you can trust it was an unintentional oversight, but I don’t think there is an example to be found.
Can I see Deborah’s side? Do I understand what prompted her to email me?
Actually, I can and I do. I realize now, after wading through all the comments/forums/blogs that what she was trying to tell me in the first place was “don’t take our recipe, make modifications to it in print, and then say that it is a recipe ‘via Cook’s Country’ because it is not ours.”
And now here’s what I think the problem is with that.
They don’t want a blogger to post a recipe verbatim as that would be “violating their copyright and would be illegal.” They grant permission to use it if it remains entirely unchanged, but are very strict about that point.
So what if you make a change to it?
And sure, those taking up the fight of ATK/CI/CC can argue all they want that they “have the right” to behave this way. And I guess they do. Legally, they’re not doing anything technically wrong by having these rules in place. And the question of whether or not I did anything illegal has been discussed and answered at length so I’m not going to expound on that any further.
But if you put that argument aside, if you just take all the legal stuff and ins and outs of my particular situation and forget about that for a minute, what remains is what I find most troubling about this entire fiasco, what it seems most people find most troubling, and that is this...
I can’t help but come to the conclusion that
For further proof of this, let me quote an interview with Chris Kimball from the Washington Post:
How much room do your books and magazine leave for creativity and interpretation?
None. Make the damn recipe my way. [He laughs.] I had someone write in a long time ago and say, "Lidia [Bastianich] cooks with her heart." And I wrote back and said, "Well, yeah, that's the wrong organ. You should use your brain." Until you know that recipe inside out and you really get it and you can make it without looking at the recipe, don't play with it. It's sort of like saying: "I'm going to play a Bach sonata. But I'm going to change the key." No. You play it the way he wrote it.
O_O
I think he makes it blatantly clear what his take on our creative liberties is. I’m not even going to remark on the fact that he insulted my dear Lidia. For the rest of the article with more lovely quotes, click here (and thank you to the Serious Eats member who pointed it out).
In theory, I appreciate what
They seem to convey the idea that we should sacrifice authenticity (see any of their "ethnic" recipes) or complex flavor or our own inspiration and creativity for step-by-step rigid instruction. They literally think their way is best. And I just don’t support that attitude when it comes to food, just as I didn’t in my past, with music and writing. We all have our personal touches and our own experience and preferences that we joyfully add to any creative pursuit. To see it any other way just saddens me.
As a final note, more than anything, I am filled with awe and gratitude that my post could have generated such support and encouragement. I am so incredibly honored by everyone who contributed to this discussion. Having nothing to do with who is “right” or “wrong,” it has been an emotionally rejuvenating experience to see just how tied together we all are.
The food blog community has been invaluable to me as a serious learning tool and a source of inspiration and amusement. I am appreciative of every single one of you that commented and linked. I read what all of you had to say and I look forward to visiting so many of you in the future and seeing what you have to say and to cook. I can't wait to discover new recipes, make new friends, and continue to learn and grow. Thank you so, so much.
~With love~














