Roundedness

In phonetics, vowel roundedness is the rounding of the lips, or lack thereof, during the articulation of a vowel. It is the degree and kind of labialization of a vowel. In the International Phonetic Alphabet vowel chart, rounded vowels are the ones that appear on the right in each bulleted pair of letters, and the corresponding unrounded vowels are the ones on the left, with [a] (when central) and the unpaired vowels [ɐ] and [ə] being neutral or unspecified. In most dialects of English, the vowel with the greatest degree of rounding is /u/, as in the word too, though some languages have significantly greater rounding of their /u/ vowel.

The contrary articulation to rounded is spread lips, in which the corners of the mouth are pulled away from each other but the lips remain fairly close together. In English, as in most languages, the vowel with the greatest lip-spreading is /i/, as in the word see.^[1]

When a (back) rounded vowel is pronounced, the lips form a circular opening that is typically wider or smaller according to how open or close the vowel is, while unrounded vowels are pronounced with the lips either spread or relaxed (neutral between spread and rounded). The degree of lip-spreading also correlates with the height of the vowel. In most languages, front vowels are spread and back vowels rounded; acoustically, this helps distinguish back vowels from front. However, some languages, such as French and German, contrast rounded and unrounded front vowels, and others, like Vietnamese, contrast rounded and unrounded back vowels. Turkish contrasts rounded and unrounded among both front and back vowels. The kind of rounding typically found with front and back vowels differs, though this detail is not commonly specified in descriptions of languages unless it's atypical.

Alekano is unusual in having only unrounded vowels.^[2]

The primary and secondary cardinal vowels of the IPA are defined on clines of roundedness, which reflect typical articulation across languages. Generally, both spreading and rounding become more significant as the height of the vowel increases.^[3] Open vowels typically have a neutral lip position – that is, neither rounded nor spread – because the open jaw allows for limited articulation of the lips.^[4]

Among the IPA primary cardinal back vowels [ɑ ɔ o u], this ranges progressively from a neutral (relaxed) lip position in [ɑ], through open (loose) rounding in [ɔ], more substantial rounding in [o], to closely (tightly) rounded [u]. The secondary cardinal vowel [ɒ] lies between [ɑ] and [ɔ], and the rounded front vowels [ɶ œ ø y] follow a cline of rounding parallel to the back vowels [ɒ ɔ o u].^[5]

Among the IPA primary cardinal front vowels [a ɛ e i], which are all unrounded, there is a similar cline from neutral [a], through slightly spread lips in [ɛ], more substantial spreading in [e], to fully spread [i]. The back unrounded vowels [ɑ ʌ ɤ ɯ] follow a parallel cline of lip-spreading.^[6]

The IPA cardinal close central vowels [ɨ ʉ] are fully spread and closely rounded, respectively.^[6] The degrees of rounding and spreading of the non-cardinal central vowels is not made explicit by the IPA, but implicitly they follow the cardinal vowels of the same height. Thus, parallel and increasing rounding (from neutral-lip to open-rounded to close-rounded) can be expected from the sets of increasingly close vowels:

[a ɑ] < [ɶ ɒ] < [œ ɞ ɔ] < [ø ɵ o] < [y ʉ u]

Similarly, increasing spreading (from neutral-lip to spread-lip) can be expected from the sets of increasingly close vowels:

[a ɑ] < [ɛ ɜ ʌ] < [e ɘ ɤ] < [i ɨ ɯ]

Vowels that do not have the expected degree of rounding from the IPA letter they are transcribed with may be clarified as more or less rounded with the over-rounding diacritic U+0339 ◌̹ COMBINING RIGHT HALF RING BELOW and the under-rounding diacritic U+031C ◌̜ COMBINING LEFT HALF RING BELOW. These diacritics specify that the vowel lies further toward the rounded or spread end of the roundedness cline.

Thus, [o̜] has less rounding than cardinal [o] (closer to the open rounding of cardinal [ɔ] or even [ɒ]), and [o̹] has greater rounding (closer to that of cardinal [u]). These diacritics are also used with unrounded vowels: [ɛ̜] is more spread than cardinal [ɛ] (closer to [e] or even [i]), and [ɯ̹] is less spread than cardinal [ɯ] (closer to [ɤ] or a more open vowel); it may or may not be slightly rounded.^[7][8]

Example 1

Protruded rounding

Compressed rounding

Example 2

Protruded rounding

Compressed rounding

There are two main types of vowel rounding: protrusion and compression, with various terminology. In protruded rounding, the corners of the mouth are drawn together and the lips protrude like a tube, with their inner surface visible. In compressed rounding, the corners of the mouth are drawn together, but the lips are also drawn together horizontally ("compressed") and do not protrude, with only their outer surface visible. That is, in protruded vowels the inner surfaces of the lips form the opening (thus the alternate term endolabial), whereas in compressed vowels it is the margins of the lips which form the opening (thus exolabial – see § Terminology). Back and central rounded vowels, such as German /o/ and /u/, are typically protruded, whereas front rounded vowels such as German /ø/ and /y/ are typically compressed.^[9] Back or central compressed vowels and front protruded vowels are uncommon,^[a] and a contrast between the two types has been found to be phonemic in only one instance.^[b]

There are no dedicated IPA diacritics to represent the distinction, but the superscript IPA letter ⟨◌ᵝ⟩ or ⟨◌ᶹ⟩ can be used for compression^[c] and ⟨◌ʷ⟩ for protrusion. Compressed vowels may be pronounced either with the corners of the mouth drawn in, by some definitions rounded, or with the corners spread and, by the same definitions, unrounded.^[d] The distinction may be transcribed ⟨ʉᵝ uᵝ⟩ vs ⟨ɨᵝ ɯᵝ⟩ (or ⟨ʉᶹ uᶹ⟩ vs ⟨ɨᶹ ɯᶹ⟩) for vowels analyzed as rounded and unrounded.^[e] An old IPA convention of rounding an unrounded vowel letter like ⟨i⟩ with a subscript omega, ⟨i̫⟩, and unrounding a rounded letter like ⟨u⟩ with a turned omega, ⟨u᫦⟩,^[13] has been conventionalized as ⟨◌̫⟩ for protruded and to ⟨◌᫦⟩ for compressed.^[14]

The distinction between protruded back [u] and compressed front [y] holds for the back and front rounded semivowels [w] and [ɥ], which are typically protruded and compressed, respectively. In general, the kind of rounding of the semivowels is found in any other labialized consonants in the language. In Akan, for example, labio-palatal [ɥ] is compressed, as are labio-palatalized consonants as in Twi [tɕᶣi̘] "Twi" and adwuma [adʑᶣu̘ma] "work", whereas labio-velar [w] and labio-velarized consonants are protruded. (Only plain labio-velarization is phonemic in Akan; the compression arises from phonetic assimilation between the labialization of the consonant and the lip-spreading of a following front vowel, which palatalizes the consonant.)^[15] Compare also the unusual rounding of Tillamook vowels and consonants below.

The protruded–compressed distinction is rarely relevant to other consonants. In Southern Teke, the sole language reported to have a phonemic /ɱ/, the labiodental sound is "accompanied by strong protrusion of both lips",^[16] whereas the [ɱ] found as an allophone of /m/ before /f, v/ in languages such as English is not protruded, as the lip contacts the teeth along its upper or outer edge. Also, in at least one account of speech acquisition of English, a child's pronunciation of clown involves a lateral [f] in which the upper teeth contact the upper, outer edge of the lip, but in crown, a median [f] is pronounced so that the teeth contact the inner surface of the protruded lower lip.^[17]

Some vowels transcribed with rounded IPA letters may not be rounded at all, and instead achieve the acoustic effect of roundedness by other (internal) articulatory means. An example is /ɒ/, the vowel of lot, which in Received Pronunciation has very little (if any) rounding of the lips. According to some linguists, the "throaty" sound of the vowel is instead accomplished with sulcalization,^[18] a furrowing of the back of the tongue also found in /ɜː/, the vowel of nurse in non-rhotic accents.^[f] Before the language went extinct, Tillamook was reported to have had "internal rounding" for /u/ and /w/ (as well as for its rounded sets of velar and uvular consonants) that was produced by a "cupping of the tongue, not by any rounding of the lips",^[19] but it is unclear from the limited description if this refers to the same feature as sulcalization.

It is possible to mimic the acoustic effect of rounded vowels by narrowing the cheeks, so-called "cheek rounding", which is inherent in back protruded (but not front compressed) vowels. The technique is used by ventriloquists to mask the visible rounding of back vowels like [u].^[20] It is not clear if it is used by languages with rounded vowels that do not use visible labial rounding, such as Seneca and other Northern Iroquoian languages, or if they are more like Tillamook.

The varied competing terms for protrusion and compression can be easy to confuse. Pairs of terms include:

Henry Sweet noted in 1890 that "the term 'inner rounding' derives from the use of the inner surfaces of the lips; the synonymous 'outrounding' derives from the forward projection of the lips. Both terms are justifiable, but their coexistence is likely to lead to serious confusion."^[22] There is no such proliferation of terms for lip-spreading.

As noted above, when strictly following the IPA, superscript letters can be used to distinguish protruded and compressed vowels. However, such a transcription could be misread as indicating diphthongization. Another possibility is to use the two retired IPA diacritics for over/under-rounding, ⟨◌̫⟩ for protruded and its inverse, ⟨◌᫦⟩, for compressed.

Central vowels may be indicated with a trema ⟨◌̈⟩,^[g] occasionally doubled to indicate a greater degree, but both more precisely mean centralized and not necessarily central. The IPA convention of barred ⟨ɨ⟩, ⟨ɵ⟩ and ⟨ʉ⟩ is sometimes extended to other letters to indicate that the vocoid (vowel or semivowel) is truly central.^[24][25] See nonstandard symbols in the IPA for further sources.

The charts below list (para-)IPA transcriptions of attested vocoid positions that contrast spread, compressed, and protruded roundedness.

Protruded rounding is the vocalic equivalent of consonantal labialization. Thus, rounded vowels and labialized consonants affect one another by phonetic assimilation: Rounded vowels labialize consonants, and labialized consonants round vowels.

In many languages, such effects are minor phonetic detail, but in others, they become significant. For example, in Vietnamese, the velar codas /k/ and /ŋ/ are labialized [kʷ] and [ŋʷ] or even labial-velar [kp] and [ŋm] after the rounded vowels /u/ and /o/.^{[citation needed]}

In the Northwest Caucasian languages of southern Russia and Georgia, and Arrernte of central Australia, what were historically rounded vowels transferred their roundedness to adjacent consonants, producing large series of phonemically labialized consonants while they themselves became unrounded in the process.

Vowel pairs differentiated by roundedness can be found in some British dialects (such as the Cardiff dialect, Geordie and Port Talbot English) as well as in General South African English and New Zealand English. They involve a contrastive pair of close-mid vowels, with the unrounded vowel being either SQUARE /ɛər/ or a monophthongal FACE /eɪ/ and the rounded counterpart being NURSE /ɜːr/. Contrasts based on roundedness are rarely categorical in English and they may be enhanced by additional differences in height, backness or diphthongization.^{[26][27][28][29]}

In addition, contemporary Standard Southern British English as well as Western Pennsylvania English contrast STRUT with LOT mostly by rounding. An example of a minimal pairs is nut vs. not. The vowels are open-mid [ʌ, ɔ] in the former dialect and open [ɑ, ɒ] in the latter. In Western Pennsylvania English, the LOT class also includes the THOUGHT class (see cot-caught merger) and the PALM one (see father-bother merger). In addition, LOT may be longer than STRUT due to its being a free vowel: [ɒː]. In SSBE, these are all distinct and LOT is a checked vowel. In Scottish English, the two vowels tend to be realized as [ʌ] and [ɔ], respectively. The latter often includes the THOUGHT class as the cot-caught merger is common in Scotland. If THOUGHT is distinct, it is realized as [ɔ], whereas LOT is lowered to [ɒ] or raised to [o̞]. This means that while nought [nɔʔ] contrasts with nut [nʌʔ] by rounding, not may have a different vowel [nɒʔ ~ no̞ʔ]. In addition, all three vowels are short in Scotland (see Scottish vowel length rule), unless followed by a voiced fricative where THOUGHT (and LOT, if they are merged) is long, as in England.^[34][35][36]

General South African English is unique among accents of English in that it can feature up to three front rounded vowels, with two of them having unrounded counterparts.^[28]

The potential contrast between the close-mid [øː] and the open-mid [œː] is hard to perceive by outsiders, making utterances such as the total onslaught [ðə ˈtœːtl̩ ˈɒnsloːt] sound almost like the turtle onslaught [ðə ˈtøːtl̩ ˈɒnsloːt].^[38]

• Close back compressed vowel [uᵝ] (in Japanese and Swedish)
• Near-close back compressed vowel [ʊᵝ] (in Swedish)
• Close central compressed vowel [ÿ] (in Norwegian)
• Mid central compressed vowel [ø̈] (in Swedish)
• Close front compressed vowel [y] (in French, German, etc.)
• Mid front compressed vowel [ø] (in French, German, etc.)
• Close front protruded vowel [yʷ] (in Swedish)
• Near-close front protruded vowel [ʏʷ] (in Swedish)
• Close-mid front protruded vowel [øʷ] (in Swedish)
• Open-mid front protruded vowel [œʷ] (in Swedish)
• Close central protruded vowel [ʉ]
• Mid central protruded vowel [ɵ]
• Close back protruded vowel [u] (common)
• Mid back protruded vowel [o] (common)
• List of phonetics topics

• The dictionary definition of endolabial at Wiktionary
• The dictionary definition of exolabial at Wiktionary
• The dictionary definition of unrounded at Wiktionary