Skip to content

Emphasis Dots (text-emphasis) and Fonts #446

Open
@bobbytung

Description

@bobbytung

Hello JLREQ folks!

There is a quite old issue confusing me for years.

傍点 (emphasis dots) in Japanese is also 着重号 in Simplified Chinese. It's not used in Taiwan, but more and more translated novels from Japanese used this way for emphasis.

This requirement is fulfilled by CSS properties "text-emphasis" and supported by browser with vertical writing many years ago.

But the implement depends on font design. Only a few Japanese fonts can display as intended. With other fonts, line-height will be expanded to break layout.

Here's a sample: Oe Kenzaburo's novel in TC. line-height set to 1.7, and obviously expanded by emphasis dots.
截圖 2024-10-31 清晨6 43 32

I've found that Apple's system font, such as Hiragino Mincho, Yu Mincho...the glyphs used by text-emphasis are designed with narrow width as this:

截圖 2024-10-31 清晨6 46 23

But most all the other TC / SC / JP fonts are using width 1000 as default. That will cause line-height broadened.

I've filed an issue on Webkit rader several years ago. But nothing changed.

I'd like to hear your opinion and figure out how to solve this old problem.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    i:emphasisEmphasis & highlightingl:jaJapanesequestionQuestions about how Japanese works. These issues should be tracked in i18n-activity tracker.s:jpanJapanese script

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions