Skip to main content

Return to Question

Post Timeline

4
duplicates list edited from Is there a point in improving a completely unclear and badly formatted question? to There is no shame in using "Skip", Is there a point in improving a completely unclear and badly formatted question?, How should I treat a suggested edit to a VLQ question? [duplicate]
Link
TylerH
TylerH
  • 21.3k
  • 23
  • 263
  • 384
Post Closed as "Duplicate" by TylerH discussion
Post Reopened by Unmitigated, Gimby, Mark Harrison, Code Lღver, Ryan MMod
Post Closed as "Duplicate" by gnat, Robert Longson, il_raffa, Donald Duck is with Ukraine, nbk
edited tags
Link
Donald Duck is with Ukraine
Donald Duck is with Ukraine
  • 9.1k
  • 4
  • 38
  • 61
Replaced "enter image description" with alt text.
Source Link
BSMP
BSMP
  • 4.9k
  • 10
  • 89
  • 109

I am quite new to the edit review queue and am keen to make sure I make the right decision on whether to accept or reject an edit.

I rejected this edit since it basically does nothing to improve what is a very poor post other than to add some formatting. Something to do with excrement and polishing comes to mind. However, 2 other high-rep users approved the edit. Should I be rejecting edits like this?

enter image description hereEdit to a question with -6 score changes one line of text in bold to one line of text and a block of pre-formatted output. The one sentence and output is the only content in the question.

I am quite new to the edit review queue and am keen to make sure I make the right decision on whether to accept or reject an edit.

I rejected this edit since it basically does nothing to improve what is a very poor post other than to add some formatting. Something to do with excrement and polishing comes to mind. However, 2 other high-rep users approved the edit. Should I be rejecting edits like this?

enter image description here

I am quite new to the edit review queue and am keen to make sure I make the right decision on whether to accept or reject an edit.

I rejected this edit since it basically does nothing to improve what is a very poor post other than to add some formatting. Something to do with excrement and polishing comes to mind. However, 2 other high-rep users approved the edit. Should I be rejecting edits like this?

Edit to a question with -6 score changes one line of text in bold to one line of text and a block of pre-formatted output. The one sentence and output is the only content in the question.

Became Hot Meta Post
Source Link
user438383
user438383
  • 6.3k
  • 1
  • 19
  • 26

Was I right to reject this edit?

I am quite new to the edit review queue and am keen to make sure I make the right decision on whether to accept or reject an edit.

I rejected this edit since it basically does nothing to improve what is a very poor post other than to add some formatting. Something to do with excrement and polishing comes to mind. However, 2 other high-rep users approved the edit. Should I be rejecting edits like this?

enter image description here