Questions tagged [comments]
Comments are small addendum to each question or answer, intentionally limited in size and formatting, and second-class citizens.
1,519 questions
9
votes
0
answers
62
views
Comments UI change: If you edit a previous comment while writing a new one, your new draft disappears
In the new comments UI, if you're writing a comment or reply then edit a previous comment, your new draft disappears without warning.
Steps with screenshots:
Start writing a reply or a new comment
...
14
votes
0
answers
99
views
Comments UI change: If you press Escape while writing a comment, your draft disappears
In the new comments UI, if you go to comment on an answer but press Esc, what you typed disappears and the comment box closes. I hope this isn't by design, cause I just lost a long comment I was ...
20
votes
0
answers
189
views
Opinion-based questions should distinguish between answers and comments
I come across a lot of "answers" to opinion-based questions in review queues that don't actually answer the question. I've noticed many of these are either requests for clarification on the ...
9
votes
0
answers
153
views
Unable to comment on question and answers to "Advice" question?
Is it a bug, or a design change? I cannot comment on python3.14 returns error but output is still correct and one other I looked at. I have commented before, so it's not a reputation limit. There ...
6
votes
0
answers
118
views
Comments can be added on "answers" to opinion-based questions from review queues
I came across this "answer" in the first answers review queue and more out of curiosity than anything shared feedback using the Community bot. Afterwards, I noticed that the actual ...
1
vote
0
answers
261
views
Cannot post comment on an existing Answer
I am a long-time user of Stack Overflow and have posted many questions and comments. Today, trying to comment on this answer, I get a response that the comment is a suspicious request, and I am not ...
25
votes
0
answers
184
views
"Answer" converted to comment on opinion-based question, but they don't have comments
I just went to delete an opinion-based question, as it wasn't asking for opinions and was also off-topic to Stack Overflow. As the OP had, however, cross posted it on the correct site, I left an "...
-4
votes
1
answer
256
views
Comment replies no longer working, error in console [duplicate]
Since a week ago, replying to comments in my own answers stopped working.
When you click the Reply button, this is the output I get into the javascript console:
Uncaught TypeError: ft.Z_ is not a ...
49
votes
0
answers
270
views
Uninvolved 1-rep users can comment on protected posts in ways that subvert the purpose of protecting the post [duplicate]
While handling flags, I came across this answer post where in the past ~3 months, several 1-rep users have commented code dumps onto the top answer posts. The question has many views and is protected, ...
25
votes
0
answers
155
views
Comments are dated "Over a year ago" instead of with the date posted [duplicate]
I use Stack Overflow to solve problems with various programming languages. Over time, these languages often get updates that change how they work, and in turn helpful users sometimes — but not always ...
28
votes
0
answers
135
views
Comments UI change: Please add back flagged icon
When I've flagged a comment, the UI used to show a little red flag symbol, but it doesn't anymore.
This icon is helpful when re-reading a list of comments so that you know that you can skip the ...
54
votes
0
answers
292
views
Highly-upvoted comments no longer stand out in the new comments UI
One of the most important purposes of comments is to flag important caveats, exceptions, issues or clarifications on an answer: "This didn't work for me until I did...", "This has been ...
5
votes
1
answer
91
views
Show NN more comments links not working on new comments UI
The "Show N more comments" links on answers doesn't do anything. For examples, try expanding the comments on the answers here and here. This only appears to be a problems for answer, not ...
4
votes
0
answers
71
views
Why can't I comment on an answer to my question? [duplicate]
I've got an answer to a question I asked yesterday.
Now I was going to comment to ask further clarification, but clicking on the "Add a comment" button has no effect.
Since I've always been ...
31
votes
0
answers
224
views
"Vote up" and "vote up" privileges poorly documented
Related: Why did I just get a notification about earning the Vote Up privilege?
Now that the much-derided experiment on comment voting requirements seems to have been graduated and the voting ...