About
CEO building the economic infrastructure for AI-driven commerce.
Over the course…
Over the course…
Articles by Matt
-
Visibility Isn't Value: The Missing Layer in AI Commerce
Visibility Isn't Value: The Missing Layer in AI Commerce
The AI era isn't creating a visibility problem. It's exposing a value problem.
6 Comments
Activity
3K followers
-
Matt Gilbert shared thisIn June 2025, I started speaking and writing publicly about how AI could reshape affiliate and performance marketing. The question I’ve kept coming back to since is increasingly fundamental: What happens when AI influences a commercial decision, but the click that historically made that influence visible disappears? I’ve spent much of the time since working through the implications of that question. Last week, I argued that the AI citation risks becoming this era’s Facebook Like: an important observable signal that is useful to measure, but dangerous to confuse with economic value. That was the first of five pieces I’m publishing with Partnerize to develop the argument I’ve been working on publicly since then: what performance marketing needs to become when commercial influence can no longer be assumed to produce a click. The second is out today. For this one, I went back to an earlier technology transition I had the opportunity to experience firsthand. More than two decades ago, I was at Ask Jeeves as search was becoming a mainstream interface for navigating the internet. Early SEO was dominated by what we could see: Where do we rank? For which searches? Who appears ahead of us? Those questions mattered. But search became economically consequential when the question changed: What happened because we were there? Rankings connected to traffic. Traffic to conversion. Conversion to revenue. Eventually, measurement became sophisticated enough to help businesses answer a much more important question: Where should the next dollar go? There was one critical piece of infrastructure connecting those worlds: The click. The click wasn’t the value. It was the observable bridge between discovery and what happened next. AI can remove that bridge without removing the commercial influence. That’s why I don’t believe the emerging AI measurement market ends with citations, visibility scores or even Share of Shortlist™. Those are important signals, and companies should be learning from them now. But mature measurement disciplines eventually have to connect what they observe to economic outcomes and capital allocation. That’s the argument I explore in installment two: I Watched Search Become a Measurement Discipline. AI Is Next. 👉 https://lnkd.in/g9TZA8Ci. This is the second of five pieces. In the three that follow, I’ll keep looking backward to understand what history can teach us about what needs to be built next. The parallels are becoming more interesting. So are the differences. We are still early enough that the rules of this market are being written. I believe our industry has an opportunity to help write them. #AIMarketing #PerformanceMarketing #AICommerce
-
Matt Gilbert shared thisI think the AI citation is becoming this era’s Facebook Like. There was a time when brands accumulated Likes, followers and fans because those were the signals we could see and measure. They weren’t meaningless. We just confused what was measurable with what was valuable. Eventually, the question changed: What is a Like actually worth? I think AI commerce is approaching the same moment. Right now, an enormous amount of energy is going into AI visibility: citations, mentions, prompt coverage, competitive visibility. All useful. But visibility is not value. The more interesting question is what happens next: Did that visibility influence consideration? Can we verify the contribution? And ultimately, what was it worth? That’s the transition I’ve been thinking about: from visibility to influence, and from influence to economic value. I wrote about why the history of the Facebook Like may be a useful warning for where AI commerce is headed, and why the next phase will require more than better dashboards. The first phase of AI commerce is about visibility. The next phase will be about value. Full piece: https://lnkd.in/etHTWUtf
-
Matt Gilbert shared thisSome people are simply a force of nature. Vanja Wilson is one of them. She is an exceptional leader, but more importantly, a very special human being. Her strength, energy and determination lift everyone around her. Life has a way of delivering perspective, sometimes in ways we would never choose. When bad things happen to good people, you can’t always control the hand you’re dealt. You can control how you play it. Vanja plays to win. She has taken something deeply personal and turned it outward, into action, awareness and an opportunity to help others. I have enormous admiration for that. It’s wonderful to see so many people across Partnerize and our broader community rally around what she is doing. A force of nature, doing what she does best. Turning adversity into action. 💙Matt Gilbert shared this✨ Influence for Good ✨ We’re officially counting down to a very special afternoon at Icebergs Bondi on the 24th September and we’re already close to capacity! Partnerize is bringing together some brilliant people across brands, publishers, agencies and creators to raise awareness and funds for the Ovarian Cancer Research Foundation (OCRF) a cause incredibly close to our hearts and to our wonderful APAC GM Vanja Wilson 💙 Expect an afternoon filled with good people, a great cause, plenty of frocks 👗 and hopefully a LOT of noise across our feeds as we use our collective influence for something that really matters. If you’ve been thinking about joining us, now is the time (there aren’t many spots left)! Registration link in comments.
-
Matt Gilbert shared thisFor years, marketing has optimized for visibility. The AI era is teaching us that visibility isn't the objective. Value is. The next competitive battleground won't be who appears most often in AI-generated answers. It will be who earns consideration, proves commercial influence, and creates the confidence to invest. I believe we're entering a new phase of digital commerce. One where measurement alone isn't enough. The market will need a trusted economic infrastructure to measure, verify, govern and ultimately reward commercial influence. In this article, I share why I believe Share of Shortlist™ will become the defining metric of the AI era, and why visibility isn't value. I'm interested to hear where others think we're headed. Are we still optimizing for visibility, or are we beginning to optimize for value?Visibility Isn't Value: The Missing Layer in AI CommerceVisibility Isn't Value: The Missing Layer in AI Commerce
-
Matt Gilbert shared thisSeeing influence isn't the same as rewarding it. For two years, the industry debated whether AI-mediated discovery had broken traditional attribution. That debate is largely over. The APMA's new report is the clearest independent confirmation yet: influence increasingly happens without a click, and the models we've relied on were never built to recognize or reward it. The report gives the industry something important: a shared language for understanding AI influence. Retrieval. Citation. Outcome. We should adopt it. But measurement is only the beginning. Visibility doesn't create economic value. Governed commercial evidence does. We've seen this before. Viewability gave advertising a common measurement standard, but standards didn't move budgets. The commercial infrastructure built on top of them did. AI-mediated discovery is at its own viewability moment. The next chapter isn't measuring influence. It's turning trusted measurement into governed commercial decisions and enforceable compensation. The question isn't whether the industry needs commercial infrastructure anymore. It's whether it's ready to adopt it. Read my full perspective: https://lnkd.in/eurmt-w7 #AICommerce #PerformanceMarketing #Partnerships
-
Matt Gilbert shared thisVisibility alone does not drive recommendations. Recommendations only give content the chance to convert. That was probably the most important takeaway from my conversation with Laurie Sullivan in MediaPost about the future of publisher economics in the age of AI Search. Much of the conversation around AI has focused on visibility. Was your content cited? Were you included in an AI Overview? Did your brand appear? Those are important questions. But they're not the economic question. Visibility creates the opportunity to earn Share of Shortlist™. Recommendation creates consideration. Verified commercial value tells us whether that consideration actually influenced a purchase. As AI increasingly mediates how consumers discover and evaluate products, brands and publishers need to move beyond measuring visibility alone. We need trusted ways to connect influence to outcomes. That's the thinking behind Partnerize's Zero-Click Commerce Index™ and HaloIndex™. Not to measure who was mentioned, but to verify who created commercial value so that value can be recognized, governed, and ultimately compensated appropriately. Appreciate Laurie for continuing to explore how AI is reshaping search and the economics of digital commerce. I believe this conversation is only just beginning. https://lnkd.in/edHXRvvc #AICommerce #MarketingMeasurement #ZeroClickCommerce #MachineMediatedMarket #ShareOfShortlist
-
Matt Gilbert posted thisFor the last twenty-five years, consumers navigated the internet themselves. Increasingly, they won't. They'll ask AI to do it for them. That's what I mean by the Machine-Mediated Market. The interface isn't the most important story. The economics are. Every market ultimately depends on trusted ways to answer four questions: • Who created value? • How do we measure it? • How do we govern it? • How should it be rewarded? For years, the click was our best observable signal. It was never the value itself. As commerce becomes increasingly machine-mediated, the challenge isn't simply measuring more signals. It's turning those signals into trusted economic outcomes. At Partnerize, we've spent the past year building around a simple belief: The Machine-Mediated Market is the environment. Economic infrastructure is what will determine who wins within it. Over the past year, my own thinking has evolved. I started by focusing on AI. Today, I'm much more focused on the economic infrastructure that will enable AI-driven commerce to function at scale. I recently had the opportunity to discuss these ideas with Sol Wilkinson at Hello Partner. One thing has become increasingly clear to me: The future of partnership marketing isn't about defending the click. It's about connecting outcome to influence. Interview link in the first comment. 👇
-
Matt Gilbert posted thisFor two decades, digital commerce has operated on a simple assumption: If there wasn't a click, there wasn't measurable value. AI just proved that assumption wrong. The industry has responded by measuring more signals, more visibility, more citations, and more AI presence. But here's the real question: How much commercial value did any of that actually create? Today, Partnerize published the 2026 Zero-Click Commerce Index™ to help answer that question. Across six consumer categories, we found publishers generated 3.84x more measurable purchase influence than traditional last-click attribution recognized. This isn't just another AI visibility metric. It's evidence that the economic model underpinning digital commerce is beginning to change. Signals don't create economic value. Trusted measurement and governance do. The next era of commerce won't be defined by who can measure more signals. It will be defined by who can measure commercial value, verify it, govern it, and compensate it with confidence. Full report in the first comment. #AICommerce #DigitalCommerce #MarketingMeasurement #ZeroClickCommerce
-
Matt Gilbert posted thisOne observation stayed with me after yesterday's Partnerize Partnership Day in London. AI visibility is becoming table stakes. It was always going to. The recent wave of AI visibility announcements isn't surprising. Every emerging market follows a familiar pattern. First we learn where we appear. Then everyone builds dashboards to measure it. That is healthy. It validates the market. But visibility isn't the destination. It's the starting point. We are now in a Machine-Mediated Market where AI systems increasingly determine which brands consumers will consider before a human ever makes a purchase decision. There's an important difference between being visible and being recommended. A brand can appear in an AI response because it's being criticized, compared unfavorably, or explicitly ruled out. Presence alone tells us very little about commercial value. Commercial value begins when a brand earns a recommendation. Consumers won't evaluate every brand an AI mentions. They'll evaluate the handful it recommends. That's why I believe Share of Shortlist may become one of the defining commercial metrics of the AI era. Knowing your brand was recommended is only the beginning. Which publisher influenced that recommendation? What content contributed to it? Did it create demand? Did it generate revenue? Should investment shift? Who should be compensated? Can the outcome be independently verified? Those aren't visibility questions. They're commercial governance questions. We've seen this movie before. Viewability became a commodity. Attention became the differentiator. Eventually, the conversation moved beyond measurement altogether toward outcomes and accountability. AI commerce is following the same path. Every major commercial shift eventually develops trusted economic infrastructure. Digital advertising did. Mobile advertising did. Programmatic did. AI commerce will too. The long-term question isn't who measures AI visibility. It's who becomes the trusted economic infrastructure for a Machine-Mediated Market. Visibility gets you noticed. Recommendation gets you considered. Verification determines what that recommendation was worth. Economic infrastructure creates markets. #PartnershipDaylondon2026 #PDLDN26 #AffiliateMarketing #PartnerMarketing #AI #Attribution #ZeroClick #PerformanceMarketing #Partnerize
Matt Gilbert replied to a comment
1w
Tim de Rosen, I think that’s a fair distinction in where the observation is taken. A decision-intent prompt is certainly an interesting subset of recommendation behavior to measure.
The question I think is still open is whether the model making a choice is itself a “win,” or another observable signal of influence. The consumer may accept it, reject it, choose another member of the shortlist, continue researching, or ultimately buy something else.
That gap between model recommendation and consumer action is exactly why I think the next frontier is connecting these increasingly sophisticated signals to verified commercial outcomes. Good discussion.
Matt Gilbert replied to a comment
1w
Tim de Rosen, thanks for the thoughtful comment. I’d frame it a little differently.
Share of Shortlist measures the frequency with which a brand appears among the recommendations generated for a defined decision context across repeated AI observations, relative to its competitive set. That matters because model preference isn’t static, and the answer engine doesn’t necessarily select a single “winner.” Recommendations can vary across repeated observations and frequently include multiple brands.
Where I’d draw a harder distinction is at verification. Whether we measure recommendation frequency or identify a model’s preferred choice in a particular response, we’re still observing model behavior. Verification requires connecting that influence to an actual commercial outcome and determining what contribution should be governed and compensated.
That distinction between measuring what the model says and verifying the economic outcome is the one I think becomes increasingly important.
-
Matt Gilbert liked thisMatt Gilbert liked thisExcited to share that Saatva CMO, Joe McCambley will be participating in #ADWEEKHouse in New York City from October 5–8 (hosted by ADWEEK during Advertising Week). We're looking forward to him joining experts from across the advertising spectrum unpack how organizations can stay relevant and drive growth in today’s rapidly changing market landscapes.
-
Matt Gilbert liked thisMatt Gilbert liked thisWe're officially two weeks out from EMARKETER's upcoming #EMARKETERSummit, Future of Digital Summit, and I just wanted to say how very excited I am to be talking about video this year. As usual, I'm just one small part of an all-star roster of speakers and presenters. Check out the full lineup here, and buy a ticket if you haven't already. https://lnkd.in/eNuNTVtd
-
Matt Gilbert reacted on thisMatt Gilbert reacted on thisI’ve been included in the 2027 edition of 𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘉𝘦𝘴𝘵 𝘓𝘢𝘸𝘺𝘦𝘳𝘴 𝘪𝘯 𝘈𝘮𝘦𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘢® for Commercial Litigation, Health Care Law, Appellate Practice, and Civil Rights Law. I especially appreciate this recognition because it includes feedback from my peers. I’m grateful to the clients and colleagues who have trusted me over the years, and to everyone who took the time to provide input. Congratulations to everyone recognized this year!
-
Matt Gilbert reacted on thisMatt Gilbert reacted on thisYesterday the Partnerize team displayed the power of partnerships by hosting the inaugural #influenceforgood fundraiser alongside Ovarian Cancer Research Foundation (OCRF) to kick off #frocktober at the stunning Icebergs Dining Room and Bar 💜 This was the first time I allowed my two worlds to truly collide, openly and vulnerably introducing my professional community to my ambassadorship. A daunting idea when first presented by the amazing Georgia Hudson, yet it felt so obvious once we started planning. What I witnessed yesterday was truly inspiring. Our guests dug deep, understood the 'why' and galvanised for our cause (to use Robin Penty's own words)! I'm not defined by my diagnosis, but I am empowered by it. I recall going for a walk with Becky Delaat the day before my first operation and she said: "One day when the dust settles and you've beat this thing, this story will be yours to share and knowing you, you'll turn it into your superpower." Yesterday, we used that power as a collective community and I couldn't be prouder. Donations are still open all of October: https://lnkd.in/ea7UMruz So many thank you's are needed: Partnerize - the team's support on the day and the ELT who cheer us on from afar. Matt Gilbert, Miranda Pokoy, Sean Sewell, Maura Smith - thank you for letting us do this! Our donations were incredible! Thank you: Reward Gateway, ShopBack, PokitPal, Think Wink LLC, CAMILLA, Kulani Kinis, Triple Whale, Emplifi, Vine Apparel, Country Road Group, Shelly Horton, Silverbean APAC and Furthr. A huge thank you to Shona Joy for my stunner of a dress and to Wear What You Feel for the generous gift bags 🩵 The wonderful Ovarian Cancer Research Foundation (OCRF) who give me hope every day. Robin Penty, Georgie Herbert, Aimee-Cherie Stefanski (nee Kendall) and my fellow ambassador Emily Jol ☺️ And B&T team who covered the event - full article here: https://lnkd.in/gqW-yZ-K And the best husband and cheerleader I could ask for Calum Wilson 🥰 Frocktober officially kicks off next week, so it's not too late to #FROCKUP for Ovarian Cancer.
-
Matt Gilbert liked thisMatt Gilbert liked thisLet's talk about Ovarian Cancer. 5 women in Australia are diagnosed with it every day The 5 year survival rate is only 49% Symptoms are usually vague (fatigue, bloating) making early detection hard, and there is no reliable early detection test And while reseach has advanced, treatments have remained relatively unchanged It is the deadliest gynaecological cancer in Australia. And it's time we change that. Yesterday I joined Partnerize's #Frocktober (frock ovarian cancer) - bringing together partnerships across our industry to shine a light on this deadly disease. The incredible Vanja Wilson took to the stage to share her lived experience after diagnosis with Stage 4 two years ago. A stage which is incredibly hard to stand on and share something so personal and so important. There wasn't a dry eye in the room afterwards. And Vanja brought together an incredible and inspirational panel to share their own experiences - including misdiagnosis, having to advocate hard to be heard, research developments and how the Ovarian Cancer Research Foundation (OCRF) are helpling drive awareness and support medical funding - raising over $37M so far to further treatments and diagnosis so far. The discussion really highlighted how important it is for us to be advocates for our own health. The stakes are too high not to be. One piece of advice from the panel on that point really stayed with me: If you ask your doctor for further investigation because something doesn't feel right and they say no, ask them to note that decision in your medical record. That simple statement quite often makes them reevaluate - and could save your life. 👉 Please check out the ovarian cancer symptoms here - it is so important to be informed and be aware > https://lnkd.in/gYYdbafE 👉 And if you would also like to support this cause - you can donate here >> https://lnkd.in/gdnNUr_B Together - we can frock ovarian cancer! 🤍🤍🤍 #Frocktober #InfluenceForGood #OCRF
-
Matt Gilbert liked thisMatt Gilbert liked thisCouldn't be prouder, 3 awards topped off by winning Gold for Best Innovation - VantagePoint and loveholidays. There's nothing like a client who is will to take something new, run with it and be successful. Congrats Aneira Henery and the VantagePoint team.
Experience & Education
Recommendations received
13 people have recommended Matt
Join now to viewOther similar profiles
Explore more posts
Explore top content on LinkedIn
Find curated posts and insights for relevant topics all in one place.
View top content