The proliferation of inappropriate and fraudulent conduct related to special calls in predatory journals has prompted GGA editors to establish stringent criteria for submitting proposals for new special calls. These criteria are in line with the recommendations published by the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ):
Proposals for Special Calls must be submitted to the Editor in Chief and include:
a) Scientific Editor Involvement
Role: A GGA Associate or Consultant Editor must serve as the Scientific Editor
Responsibilities: Review and ratify editorial recommendations, ensure no conflicts of interest, verify manuscript integrity, and guide guest editors.
b) Guest Editors
Selection: Based on expertise, diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility.
Responsibilities: Follow the submission and review process through the GGA’s Editorial Platform. Ensure a double-masked peer-review process with at least two independent reviewers per submission. Maintain confidentiality throughout the review process.
Timeliness: Aim to make editorial decisions within eight weeks of submission. All communications must occur via the editorial platform.
Content: The scientific editor and/or guest editor(s) are encouraged to submit an introductory essay outlining the call’s rationale, current knowledge, gaps, and expectations for submissions.
Quantity: Guest editors and the Scientific Editor are responsible for securing at least four invited articles from independent researchers. In addition, they must select between 8 and 12 original articles submitted to the call, with flexibility based on the Editor-in-Chief's approval.
Sponsorship: Sponsors must not influence any phase of the manuscript selection and editing process. No favors or payments are allowed for editors or reviewers.
Competing Interests: All editors must disclose potential conflicts of interest, including non-financial biases.
Appeals: The Editor-in-Chief will handle written appeals and complaints regarding post-publication issues.
Plagiarism Check: Each accepted paper undergoes a similarity check using the iThenticate tool®.
Misconduct: The editors will seek advice from COPE and evaluate on a case-by-case basis for retractions or expressions of concern, according to the GGA policies.
Volume Limit: Special calls should not exceed 50% of the journal's volume content.