7
$\begingroup$

I've just come across the following description of the history of diffraction gratings. The phrase "fifty-three apertures" sounds like the "first" described in the text is an amplitude grating (parallel line openings in a mask) rather than a phase or topography grating that we normally think of.

I wonder how and why an astronomer

  1. made (or assembled?) a diffraction grating without a ruling engine
  2. tested the grating to at least demonstrate diffraction
  3. didn't use it for some astronomical purpose after making it

Was it just for fun?


Related: Where does "the grating equation" come from? Does it have a another name?


From "Diffraction Grating Handbook", third edition, Christopher Palmer, Ed. Erwin Loewen Editor (first edition), 1996, Richardson Grating Laboratory, found here:

A BRIEF HISTORY OF GRATING DEVELOPMENT

The first diffraction grating was made by an American astronomer, David Rittenhouse, in 1785, who reported constructing a half-inch wide grating with fifty-three apertures. Apparently he developed this prototype no further, and there is no evidence that he tried to use it for serious scientific experiments.

In 1821, unaware of the earlier American report, Joseph von Fraunhofer began his work on diffraction gratings. His research was given impetus by his insight into the value that grating dispersion could have for what we now call the science of spectroscopy. Fraunhofer's persistence resulted in gratings of sufficient quality to enable him to measure the absorption lines of the solar spectrum. He also derived the equations that govern the dispersive behavior of gratings. Fraunhofer was interested only in making gratings for his own experiments, and upon his death, his equipment disappeared.

By 1850, F. A. Nobert, a Prussian instrument maker, began to supply scientists with gratings far superior to Fraunhofer's. About 1870, the scene of grating develop- ment returned to America, where L. M. Rutherfurd, a New York lawyer with an avid interest in astronomy, became interested in gratings.

In just a few years, Rutherfurd learned to rule reflection gratings in speculum metal that were larger and better than any Nobert had made. For the first time, the performance of diffraction gratings surpassed even that of the most powerful prisms. Rutherfurd made few gratings, though, and their uses were limited due to their high ghost intensities. Rutherfurd's dedication, impressive as it was, could not match the tremendous strides made by H. A . Rowland, professor of physics at the Johns Hopkins University. Rowland's work established the grating as the primary optical element of spectroscopic technology. Rowland not only constructed sophisticated ruling engines but also invented the concave grating, a device of spectacular value to modern spectroscopists. He continued to rule gratings until his death in 1901.

$\endgroup$
4
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Is there a tag related to development of instrumentation or equipment? $\endgroup$ Commented yesterday
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Rittenhouse performed his experiment in response to a request by his friend Thomas Hopkinson, who had made a curious observation when looking at a lamp through a silk handkerchief, and asked Rittenhouse for a scientific explanation of his observations: "An Optical Problem, Proposed by Mr. Hopkinson, and Solved by Mr. Rittenhouse." Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, Vol. 2, 1786, pp. 201-206. $\endgroup$ Commented yesterday
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ I don't have time to write an answer now (I'd be happy to upvote if someone else writes one), but this should address part of your question: "In order to make my experiments with more accuracy, I made a square of parallel hairs about half an inch each way. And to have them nearly parallel and equidistant, I got a watchmaker to cut a very fine screw on two pieces of small brass wire. In the threads of these screws, 106 of which made one inch, the hairs were laid 50 or 60 in number." $\endgroup$ Commented yesterday
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ As a resident of south eastern Pennsylvania I note that David Rittenhouse was mentioned in high school history books used in my era as a leading Pennsylvania citizen of his era. Rittenhouse Square in Center City Philadelphia is named after him en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rittenhouse_Square and there is a crater Rittenhouse on the far side of the Moon named after him. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rittenhouse_(crater) $\endgroup$ Commented 20 hours ago

2 Answers 2

7
$\begingroup$

As noted in the other answer by akhmeteli and comments by njuffa, there is a publication documenting the circumstance and use of the grating:

The content of the contribution was exposed in:

Given that Rittenhouse believed in Newtonian corpuscular deflection bending, he was unable to explain the phenomenon, that he clearly recognized as interesting. His closing paragraph start with:

By pursuing these experiments it is probable that new and interesting discoveries may be made [..]

The approach using hair to design the grating was in line with other work by Rittenhouse in finding the most fitting material to design telescope cross hairs, and the discovery of spider silk being the best performing material is his in the previous year (1785).

Some more detail on this can be found in:

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

So you may look at the source. I don't think I should just paraphrase it here. Just the conclusion: "want of leisure obliges me to quit the subject for the present."

$\endgroup$

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.