6
$\begingroup$

In the diagram, circles of the same color are congruent. Wherever things look tangent, they are tangent.

enter image description here

Show that the red circle is congruent with the orange circles.

I have found a solution, which I post below, but it is not easy without a computer. I am looking for a more elegant solution.

(This question was inspired by the diagram in this question about the maximum number of tangent points when $n$ circles are in a triangle.)

$\endgroup$
1
  • $\begingroup$ I asked a generalized version of this question, in which the two orange circles are not necessary mutually tangent. $\endgroup$ Commented Jan 19 at 9:35

1 Answer 1

3
$\begingroup$

Self-answering. This solution is not easy without a computer.


Assume the radius of the orange circles is $1$. Then the radius of the blue circles is $2$.

Let $g=$ radius of the green circles.

Pythagorus gives the two lengths labelled in red below:

enter image description here

Then Pythagorus with the dashed line right triangle gives:

$$\left(2\sqrt2-g\right)^2+\left(1+\sqrt{(g+1)^2-g^2}\right)^2=(g+2)^2$$

$$\implies g=\frac{4+6\sqrt2+4\sqrt{1+\sqrt2}}{9+4\sqrt2}$$

Superimpose cartesian axes with the origin at the bottom of the lower orange circle.

The equations of the right blue circle and right green circle are, respectively:

$$\left(x+2\sqrt2\right)^2+\left(y-2\right)^2=2^2$$

$$\left(x+g\right)^2+\left(y-3-\sqrt{2g+1}\right)^2=g^2$$

Let the equation of the right side of the triangle be $y=mx+k$. The right side of the triangle is tangent to both the right blue and right green circles. By setting discriminants equal to $0$, we get two equations with $m$ and $k$. We solve for $m$ and $k$. There are three pairs of solutions (corresponding to the three lines that are tangent to both circles); we choose the negative value of $m$ with smaller magnitude. We get that the equation of the right side of the triangle is:

$$y=\left(-\frac27\sqrt{2+10\sqrt2}\right)x+\frac87\left(3+\sqrt2+\sqrt{1+5\sqrt2}\right)$$

Now let $C$ be a circle of radius $1$ that is above and tangent to the two green circles. (We will show that $C$ is tangent to the sides of the triangle, which means that $C$ is the red circle.) The equation of $C$ is:

$$x^2+\left(y-3-2\sqrt{2g+1}\right)^2=1^2$$

It can be shown that $C$ is tangent to the right side of the triangle, by calculating the discriminant and finding that it equals $0$.

Thus, $C$ is the red circle, so the red circle has radius $1$, so the red circle is congruent with the orange circles.


Here is a Desmos graph of the triangle and circles.

$\endgroup$

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.