I noticed that many UK-university job apps have questions about applicants' disability status, particularly under sections called "Diversity Monitoring." Will answering this have any negative impact on your application? I know in some systems it is never recommended to indicate a disability, as it will negatively impact your chances of being offered the job...
3 Answers
Generally, your answers to these questions are handled separately from the rest of your application, and are not directly shared with the people who are making the hiring decision. Instead, HR uses the information (perhaps) to assess whether there is any evidence of bias in the recruitment and selection process.
There are of course some caveats: if you request particular accommodations within the interview process on account of your circumstances, this will inevitably be passed on to the interview panel.
Overall, there is probably not too much to be concerned about in answering these questions truthfully. Equally, there may be little direct benefit to doing so -- usually you can just opt out of answering.
I don't know about the UK, but in Germany, there are quotas most employers (especially publicly funded ones like universities) have to fulfil for a diverse portfolio of employees. This includes employees with (officially reconized) disabilities. If you as an employer have not at least some people with disabilities working for you, there might be fines or other consequences.
In many job descriptions, there is therefore a little line at the bottom that says somthing along the lines of "people with disabilities will be preferably employed when having the same qualification as non-disabled applicants" (on a side note, similar structures exist for e.g. female* applicants in male dominated fields).
My point is, in some cases it might be even beneficial to list a disability, because if a similar quota system exists in the UK (which I strongly suspect), they might be explicitly looking for qualified candidates with disabilities (as weird as that sounds) to meet quotas and avoid fines.
-
2I'm not sure there are external quotas in the UK, but certainly some universities have internal schemes of this sort. However, given the nature of academic jobs, a hiring panel can almost always find some reason why person A is 'better qualified' for the position than person B, so I'm not sure that it actually makes much difference for these roles.avid– avid2025-07-12 10:12:54 +00:00Commented Jul 12 at 10:12
-
I am not aware of quotas in Germany. Can you give a reference? My understanding is that disabled persons (and a number of other categories) are particularly protected under the Allgemeines Gleichstellungsgesetz (AGG), so that if a disabled person applies, they will be treated preferentially (as you note). Essentially, if they are not at least invited to an interview, they have a very good chance if they sue for discrimination, so employers will usually invite everyone to an interview who is officially recognized as disabled. Which, of course, is not a quota (but a similar mechanism).Stephan Kolassa– Stephan Kolassa2025-07-12 20:36:59 +00:00Commented Jul 12 at 20:36
-
3Above 20 employees in Germany a company etc. needs to employ disabled people or pay a fine(SGB IX). That looks good on paper but in reality it doesn't help you to get a job as a disabled person, because of stigma and fear that you cannot be fired if it doesn't work out. So sadly most companies just pay. It's not an advantage to get hired except for a negligible number of jobs in very big companies.pyrochlor– pyrochlor2025-07-13 06:54:42 +00:00Commented Jul 13 at 6:54
If the job is with a university signed up to the disability confident scheme such a disclosure could influence the application process, making progressing to the interview stage more likely.
-
2... providing the candidate meets all the essential criteria (or can persuasively argue reasonable accommodations can be made. This is definitely not a free pass to apply for every job you see.origimbo– origimbo2025-07-13 18:51:14 +00:00Commented Jul 13 at 18:51