3

Is there a word or phrase that describes the following condition?

Once you have an idea, you are incapable of letting go of it until you have explored it fully, that is, explored every conceivable branch from the idea and reached all possible logical conclusions (after which you can finally put it down and continue your day).

New contributor
Trigger2931 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.
4
  • 2
    Does idée fixe work? Commented yesterday
  • It's close but the wrong connotation Thank you though. I did figure it out eventually from your response though. Instead of Idea fixation it's Fixated ideation. Fixated ideation is a mental state characterized by an obsessive and consuming focus on a specific thought, idea, or topic that is difficult to disengage from Commented yesterday
  • If "Fixated ideation" answers your original question, please consider making a post below and marking it as the answer to close this question. Commented yesterday
  • @Trigger2931 Great you found your answer! For anyone else who comes across this and doesn't want to drop "fixated ideation" into their writing: "hung up (on something)" implies the person can't move on and is likely exploring every avenue to figure it out. Commented yesterday

4 Answers 4

3

The word that comes to my mind is simply obsession

the domination of one's thoughts or feelings by a persistent idea, image, desire, etc.

1
  • That was my first instinct too, but I fear it fails to convey "put it down and continue your day" after one has "reached all possible logical conclusions". Commented 16 hours ago
3

Is there a word or phrase that describes the following condition?
Once you have an idea, you are incapable of letting go of it until you have explored every conceivable branch from the idea and reached all possible logical conclusions.

Inspired by terminology from risk analysis and decision science as well as the language and framework of Myers–Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) cognitive styles

indeed, INTJs can hardly rest until they have things settled, decided, and set. They are the people who are able to formulate coherent and comprehensive contingency plans, hence contingency organizers

the following phrases capture the anticipatory and closure-driven aspects of the trait that you are describing:

  • exhaustive contingency reasoning style/preference/pattern
  • scenario-tree cognitive style/preference/pattern.

To actually characterise the trait as a condition, you could instead call it

  • scenario-tree fixation.

A related term, from psychology, is "monotropism", which is neither as precise nor particularly accurate to the OP's specific description:

Monotropism is an individual's tendency to focus their attention on a small or singular number of interests at any time, with them neglecting or not perceiving lesser interests.
...
A tendency to focus attention tightly has a number of psychological implications, with it being seen as a state of "tunnel vision".
...
this form of hyperfocus makes it harder to redirect attention
...

Finally, I think that the commenter-suggested "idée fixe" (literally, "fixed idea") crucially fails to capture the OP's core notion of generative rumination—specifically, one that cascades and branches exhaustively. Besides, this suggestion is even more loaded than the final bullet above.


Tangential; too long as a comment

I found a lot of ancillary utility in reading your answer. Particularly amusing to me was the fact that MBTI is considered psuedoscientific, yet the profile description above summarises my personality traits to a tee.

Thanks for the kind note. MBTI classifies normative cognitive/learning preferences by how individuals are most naturally inclined to engage with information (pattern-oriented vs. concrete; outward-focused vs. inward-focused) and make decisions (values-based vs. logic-based; structured vs. holistic); specifically, the interaction of these two two-dimensional factors yields 16 non-uniformly distributed cognitive patterns.

Outside the physical sciences, scientific rigour exists on a spectrum; wherever MBTI ultimately sits, the charges of pseudoscience are understandable. The framework's four dichotomies are unfortunately named ("Introversion-Extraversion", "Sensing-Intuition", "Thinking-Feeling", "Judging-Perceiving"), and its four-letter labelling system perpetuates two key misunderstandings that contribute to an impression of reductive caging: that the four dichotomies are unrelated dimensions rather than functionally interlocked, and that the model implies that cognitive tendencies have invariant expressions across contexts and regardless of ongoing developmental change.

8
  • 1
    Note that MBTI is a pseudoscientific theory that has no real weight or meaning in psychology. You don't seem to answer the question with proper citation to dictionary or other sources. Commented yesterday
  • @dubious My exact words: "Inspired by terminology from .... as well as the language/framework of ...." And each of the three links does lead to its cited source. In particular, my wording "inspired by" indicates why none is necessarily a dictionary citation of a standard term. Ultimately, for each bulleted suggestion, either it successfully evokes/matches the OP's actual given description or it doesn't. Commented yesterday
  • @ryang We prefer stand alone answers where you don't need to chase any links to get information or citations. Providing the link is appropriate, but you should excerpt the relative parts, define any uncommon terms like INTJ, and provide explicit citations. If the link rots, it still is a useful answer and the sources can be dug up again. Commented yesterday
  • @PhilSweet The links don't need to be chased, because they are supplementary (though they do provide context), and the particular label INTJ is quite immaterial. I've just added boldfacing to the excerpt, which is sufficient to explain the bulleted suggestions. Commented yesterday
  • 1
    @ryang thank you for your response. I found a lot of ancillary utility in reading your answer. Particularly amusing to me was the fact that MBTI is considered psuedo scientific but it's description summarises my personality traits to a tee Commented yesterday
0

Fixated ideation is the answer to my question.

Fixated ideation differs from ideated fixation (Idée fixe) in that Idée fixe can not progress past a thought or generate new ideas. Fixated ideation is about being hyperfocused on your rumination and following a branch analysis of the idea, its consequences and any new ideas that spawn as a result of that rumination.

The only source I could find for this answer was from AI. Which provided the following response:

Fixated ideation is a mental state where an individual has an obsessive, consuming focus on a single thought or idea that is difficult to let go of. This can manifest as rumination or intrusive thoughts and may be a symptom of a mental health condition like OCD, ADHD, or anxiety. The fixation can lead to distress, anxiety, and an inability to disengage from the thought, even if it is unproductive or nonsensical.

Key characteristics

Obsessive focus: A persistent and often unwanted preoccupation with a specific thought, idea, or topic.

Difficulty disengaging: The individual finds it hard to stop thinking about the topic, and it can interfere with daily life.

Intrusive thoughts: These are unwelcome, upsetting thoughts that can feel out of a person's control.

Rumination: A form of thought fixation that involves repeatedly thinking about problems, often in a negative cycle.

Psychological and physiological impact: Fixation can lead to stress and anxiety due to the over-activation of brain regions associated with emotion, and it can interfere with higher-level thinking and problem-solving.

When it becomes a problem

When the fixation is persistent and causes significant distress. When it prevents a person from completing tasks or interferes with their ability to function in daily life.

When the fixation is associated with other mental health conditions, such as OCD, anxiety, depression, or ADHD.

How to cope

Distraction: Engage in activities that are mentally or physically intensive, or sensation-rich, to help break the thought loop.

Mindfulness: Practice focusing on the present moment without judgment.

Cognitive restructuring: Work on reinterpreting thoughts, particularly after a mistake, to avoid getting stuck in a negative cycle.

Seek professional help: A mental health professional can provide strategies and therapies like Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) to address the underlying causes of the fixation.

New contributor
Trigger2931 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.
3
  • Your answer could be improved with additional supporting information. Please edit to add further details, such as citations or documentation, so that others can confirm that your answer is correct. You can find more information on how to write good answers in the help center. Commented yesterday
  • en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Id%C3%A9e_fixe_(psychology)#Modern_usage Commented 14 hours ago
  • I did a [google] web search on fixated ideation. I [also] did get a similar generated response from the "helpful" AI and it also now links this page as well. Total of (only) 5 pages matched. But, otherwise, no match and, personally, I've never seen this phrase before. Could this be an AI hallucination? What about just fixation [by Occam's Razor]? Commented 3 hours ago
0
  • tunnel vision - extreme narrowness of viewpoint : narrow-mindedness also : single-minded concentration on one objective. merriam-webster.com
  • one-track mind - used in reference to a person whose thoughts are preoccupied with one subject or interest. to think about one particular thing and nothing else dictionary.cambridge.org
  • preoccupied - thinking or worrying about something too much dictionary.cambridge.org

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.