4

In Sinners (2025), there's a scene where the vampires Remmick, Bert, and Joan are waiting outside the juke joint. As Mary (Hailee Steinfeld) approaches to speak with them, they are in the midst of singing the Irish folk song "Will Ye Go, Lassie Go?" (also known as "Wild Mountain Thyme"). We know this establishes Remmick, the vampire leader, as having Irish origins. This is reinforced later when the vampires sing "Rocky Road to Dublin," but I'm curious whether there's deeper meaning here.

Does the specific choice of "Will Ye Go, Lassie Go?" carry any thematic significance? Do the song's historical background, its lyrics, or its cultural context reveal anything about the vampires' motivations or provide insight into their (or specifically Remmick's) characterization beyond just establishing Remmick's Irish heritage?

1
  • The vampires really like Lassie? I mean, who doesn't like a plucky little collie who goes round saving kids from wells? Commented May 27, 2025 at 22:25

3 Answers 3

3

As with most of Sinners, there are several things going on at different levels. The choice of "Will Ye Go, Lassie, Go?" has meaning within that particular scene, and the choice of British folk music has meaning within the broader narrative.

The use of "Will Ye Go, Lassie Go" is somewhat anachronistic, in that it was first recorded in 1957, 25 years after Sinners takes place. This is entirely forgivable: The song is based on a much older one called "The Braes of Balquither", which has a similar tune and lyrical content. It's possible, as noted in the Wikipedia article, that the modern version was written much earlier and simply not recorded until the 1950s. I surmise that the producers hand-waved the anachronism away because today's audiences are more familiar with the modern version of the song. (Within the narrative, we might speculate that the 1957 recording was influenced by the characters who survive until the epilogue.)

"Will Ye Go, Lassie Go" is about enticing a lover to come out into a wild place and be together in nature by constructing a memorial to her:

I will build my love a bower
By yon clear crystal fountain,
And on it I will pile
All the flowers of the mountain.
Will you go, lassie, go?

One key difference from the original "Braes of Balquither" is that the chorus invites others to join a community of practice, each collecting wild flowers for their own respective dearies:

And we'll all go together,
To pull wild mountain thyme,
All around the purple heather.

This "group activity" aspect is reinforced by the particular arrangement used in Sinners, where all three members of Remmick's troupe take verses singing, and join together in the chorus.

In the last verse, the singer hints that the listener may become the object of his affection in time:

If my true love she'll not come,
Then I'll surely find another,
To pull wild mountain thyme,
All around the purple heather.
Will you go, lassie, go?

So, Remmick and his troupe are enticing Mary with the antithesis of what Stack represents to her:

  • A life roaming outdoors instead of tied to a single building
  • A lover who stays true to her for a long time
  • A cultural tradition rooted in the British isles, rather than West Africa

Given Mary's personal history with Stack, and her status as a "passing" white with mixed heritage, we can see why the song affects her as much as it does. The synthesis between these alternatives -- a life with Stack while he runs a juke joint, and a life roaming about with Remmick -- comes in the epilogue.

On a broader level, the use of British folk and American "roots" music for Remmick and his band calls to mind the history of rock 'n' roll, country music, bluegrass, and other American popular forms, all of which trace a mixed heritage to both the British Isles and Africa. "White artists and record producers got rich stealing from black artists" is an oversimplification of that history, but one that can be read in Sinners: When Remmick first turns up at the juke joint, he claims to stand for "music and equality," which sounds like something a 1990s A&R man might say while signing a hip-hop act. By the end of the night he reveals his true hunger to Preacher Boy: "I want your memories! I want your SONGS!"

2

First off, the person who replied saying “Will Ye Go, Lassie, Go” is a “British folk song” is inaccurate about a few things he says in his answer. The song, itself, is not British. It’s an Irish song which borrows some parts from earlier Scottish songs.

The head vampire in the film, named Remmick, is Irish. He had been turned into a vampire before he ever made it from Ireland to America. His homeland drove him out, for obvious reasons, and he fled to America to try to find a new place to make a home for himself and create a new “family” by turning everyone there into vampires.

‘Will Ye Go, Lassie, Go’ (a song that also goes by the names ‘Wild Mountain Thyme’ and ‘Purple Heather’) is an Irish song about finding love, and it does so by emphasizing the beauty of the natural world. The line “Will ye go, lassie, go” is describing a young man's invitation to a "lassie" to join him in this scenic setting, reflecting a traditional Irish courtship ritual.

The reasons this song was chosen were as follows. Firstly, it was chosen to showcase Remmick’s ancestry and allude to his age. Secondly, its lyrics symbolize him trying to lure Mary out so he can turn her into one of them, thus growing his new “family.”

2
  • What do you mean by "His homeland drove him out, for obvious reasons"? It's not obvious to me. Can you elaborate? If it was because he's a vampire, wouldn't he face the same problem wherever he goes? Commented Jul 13, 2025 at 7:05
  • Yes, it was because he was a vampire. The vampires got driven out of Ireland. No specifics are given as to exactly how, but a prequel movie would be nice. Since no one in the U.S. knew what he was, that gave him the opportunity to start over with a new plan. A plan to make a new home for himself. Hopefully being able to turn as many people as he could so that their numbers would be difficult it stop, or just unstoppable. Commented Jul 14, 2025 at 17:28
0

It's a deliberate attempt to lure Mary in.

Will ye Go, Lassie, Go? is a slow mournful song talking about the Irish who were uprooted from their home country and sent to the US where they got treated like shit by the British. By singing it they're invoking parallels between the plight of the Irish and that of the blacks in order to play on her sense of empathy and kinship and get her to let her guard down long enough to bite.

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.