7

Is it easy to move from one research topic to an other in the transition from a PhD to a postdoc?

If I ask this question to Google, it says that it can be done. This process would have even the advantage of increasing adaptability and expertises. However, if I read some postdocs advertisements (for example, UK based), I see that they require skills which are closely related to the postdoc topics.

For example, a postdoc on mathematical modelling of epilepsy seizures requires a background in AI, graph theory, neural networks, etc. I would be very interested but my PhD is in Neuroscience and Imaging and my work has mainly been to acquire and analyze magnetic resonance imaging data, and so preprocessing and processing using basics statistics to answer biological questions and MR sequences optimization, without using AI. So I feel that I am already "too out of that field" to try and be accepted.

How much is common to change field of research at this stage?

Edit: this question you suggested (How) Can I switch from field X to field Y after getting my PhD? answers to my question in a general way. It is useful but I would like concrete examples of people who did this change or of what could I do considering my situation where I am, that I explained above. The answers must be more related to how is it easy? How is it common ? And possibly giving some examples in my specific situation.

Thank you everyone!

12
  • 2
    Related, possible duplicate: (How) Can I switch from field X to field Y after getting my PhD? Commented 2 days ago
  • 1
    @cag51, my view is that it is easier to switch fields after you establish yourself, making it harder for a new PhD. Commented 2 days ago
  • 1
    This question is similar to: (How) Can I switch from field X to field Y after getting my PhD?. If you believe it’s different, please edit the question, make it clear how it’s different and/or how the answers on that question are not helpful for your problem. Commented yesterday
  • 1
    @SimonLRydinMyerson as the answer you linked is very helpful in a general way, I will modify my question making it more specific for my field and my intentions. Thank you. Commented yesterday
  • 2
    @Stef I could be wrong, but I read their statement to mean that they googled the question. Commented yesterday

3 Answers 3

14

The general answer would be no, that it isn't easy, but it isn't a yes/no situation. It depends on many things. A switch between related subfields of a general field would be easier (won't say easy) than a more radical change.

But it depends even more on what you have overall to offer to a position. If you are familiar with the research process and the nature of evidence in a field and have some experience with that, you will probably be considered, though others more closely aligned will probably have a better chance.

That said, any position you don't apply for you won't get.

I'm an outsider to your field, but your description sounds like you have some alignment. Make your case to whoever is hiring.

4

To get hired for a postdoc position, the PI needs to believe that you are the best candidate available to them. Most of the time they will have candidates available with directly related experience, so you need to somehow make the case that you are a stronger candidate.

In your example, maybe you can make the case that while you don't have the specific experience in graph theory and neural networks etc, your statistical background will allow you to pick up the machine learning side of the research relatively quickly, and you also bring a strong understanding of the subject matter which is crucial for building clinically relevant models, etc.

I have recently been talking with my supervisors about a similar switch in fields when I graduate. If your supervisors believe you are capable of making the switch, it will help a lot if you're able to lean on their networks. Do they have colleagues working in your target field that they can recommend you to? A prospective PI is much more likely to take a chance on a field-switching postdoc if that PI's trusted collaborator can explain why they believe the postdoc will be successful.

If you have time left before the end of your PhD you could try to publish something more related to your target field, or which showcases some relevant skills which are not otherwise demonstrated in your PhD project. This makes you a much less risky prospect. For example, maybe you could use a neural network in your analysis of MRI data. (There is some interesting work on MRI dataset harmonisation using neural networks, for example).

2

There is a planned move from one field to another, and then there is taking on a project out of curiosity in an area that is new to you.

A planned change of field

This is something that takes a lot of work and study, which will have to be self-directed (no-one will tell you exactly what you need to do), and which will probably be in addition to your normal duties. It is certainly possible.

You might want to spread the work out over a longer period. A typical way to go about this might be to seek a postdoc in your current field, but one with a decent amount of time for your own research. It is likely that you will need to find collaborators who already work in your target field.

A spontaneous project in a new area

This is common and much easier. It usually means a side-project, rather than a new job.

If you have a very strong research record, however, or a truly outstanding academic record in other ways, then you might well be able to secure a job in a new field on the basis that you will pick up the skills you need as you go along.

The specific example

I am in pure maths, so take this with a perfectly spherical grain of salt: I think that a postdoc in mathematical modelling probably has a rigid minimum requirement that candidates have experience, at research level, in some kind of mathematical modelling in a broad sense. You might have done something that fits the bill.

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.